Lawmaker proposes push of ’90s pot tax

A state legislator told the Jindal administration that he is not ready to go the way of Washington state and Colorado by asking voters to legalize and tax marijuana.

Instead, state Sen. Dan Claitor said, he thinks the Jindal administration is missing the opportunity to generate revenue through a decades-old law that attempts to collect taxes from the drug trade through a different angle.

A law on Louisiana’s books since the 1990s requires marijuana dealers to pay taxes on their product by buying stamps from the state revenue department or face seizure of their valuables if they are arrested.

However, little money is flowing to the state from the law, prompting Claitor, once an assistant district attorney in New Orleans, to tell the Jindal administration to either pursue the tax or get rid of it.

Other states are asking voters to legalize marijuana and tax it as a way to generate revenue. Louisiana’s approach is less direct. The state sells tax stamps and asks no questions about whether the buyer is a drug dealer or a novelty collector.

During a meeting of the Revenue Study Commission, Claitor, R-Baton Rouge, interrupted a discussion on tobacco- and alcohol-related tax breaks to ask what the state is doing to collect taxes on marijuana sales in Louisiana.

“I know there’s a lot of marijuana going through the system,” said Claitor, whose district covers much of south Baton Rouge.

Marijuana dealers are supposed to pay taxes for their illegal trade by purchasing stamps from the state revenue department. Alternatively, collection can be made when an arrest or seizure occurs, triggering reports to be filed and an assessment established.

Jason Decuir, an attorney for the revenue department, said he has not seen any assessments since he joined the agency last year.

“We essentially tell the criminal system, you guys, that’s your bailiwick,” Claitor said. “But we have the law on the books. It seems as though we ought to be making some effort to collect it.”

He noted that some areas of the country are legalizing marijuana and taxing it.

Decuir said he has looked at Louisiana’s law and determined there often are no assets to seize.

Claitor, who is a lawyer, disagreed.

“There’s cash that is seized,” he said. “I used to prosecute. It ends up going into the district attorney’s till as opposed to going to the state of Louisiana.”

Louisiana’s tax, established in the 1990s, requires dealers to pay $3.50 in taxes for each gram of marijuana.

The idea behind the law was to require dealers to buy tax stamps from the state revenue department, allowing law enforcement to seize their homes, cars and other valuables when they are caught with unstamped drugs.

For the fiscal year that ended June 30, 2010, the state collected $26,187 in marijuana and controlled substance taxes. Collections dropped to $505.53 the following year.

Presidential candidate Gary Johnson’s platform includes a push to legalize marijuana. Johnson, a Libertarian, said the criminalization of drugs is increasing incarceration rates and gang violence.

Earlier this year, Rhode Island decriminalized marijuana possession and lowered the fine from $500 to $150, putting violations on scale with a parking ticket.

Voters in Colorado and Washington state will decide in November whether to legalize and tax marijuana. Leading Republicans are backing the measures even though federal law bans marijuana use. A number of states allow marijuana to be used for medicinal purposes.

The Campaign to Regulate Marijuana Like Alcohol is airing a commercial in Colorado telling voters that a tax would create income for schools instead of drug cartels.

Claitor said he is not advocating going in the same direction as Colorado or Rhode Island. He told revenue department officials that they should pursue collecting Louisiana’s marijuana tax or seek to purge the law from the books.

After Claitor finished questioning the revenue department, state Rep. Joel Robideaux joked that he wasn’t sure what the next topic was.

“I forgot what we were doing,” said Robideaux, R-Lafayette. “It must be those cookies that Henry brought.”

State Rep. Henry Burns, R-Haughton, owns a bakery and often brings treats for legislators.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (46)


1) Comment by Protean - 09/10/2012

-> Whatwhy: Very, very poor analogy. Marijuana is generally used unaltered -- straight from the stalk (although refined versions exist). Heroin is a refined extract of the poppy. A closer analogy to heroin would be alcohol. You know, the stuff "conservative" (read "authoritarian") hypocrites have no problem consuming in great quantities, but only as long as one of their authorized directors (religious whacks) gets to tell _other_ people where, when and how they can consume it.

2) Comment by LegalizeLouisiana - 09/10/2012

One good point that everybody in the Bible Belt should know, is that Jesus Christ Himself used and distributed cannabis as a medicine and as an alchemichal spiritual agent. If you have a problem with The Word, take it up with The Father (Exodus 30:23 KNH BSM). Meanwhile, no law of man should be a stumbling block to freely living the Gospel in Louisiana. Now, what if Jesus came back, to Louisiana, giving out anointing oil? Would you nail Him, again? You'd throw the book at Him? The Truth of the matter is not to be feared; it will set us free.

3) Comment by LegalizeLouisiana - 09/10/2012

To be clear, the tax stamp specifically does not apply to legal use of marijuana and is inherently wrong. If the legislature intends to do what is right, they will remove all penalties for cannabis possession in Louisiana, immediately. They will also go to the boards of health and pharmacy, and sort out why they are not promulgating rules providing access to medicine for sick and dying people, as per the mandates of the legislature.

4) Comment by LegalizeLouisiana - 09/10/2012

Finally someone said the M word. The LA tax stamp is a bad law; in spirit, letter, and practice it is literally apartheid. Too bad the only time cannabis gets serious mention by a LA legislator, it's in support of the murkiest of revenue scams. Meanwhile, too bad dying patients are still waiting for medicine the Louisiana law supposedly allows, already. Stop wasting time, put on your big boy pants, and do your jobs.

5) Comment by nimby? - 09/10/2012

last year more deaths were attributed to people pulling vending machines on themselves than marijuana usage . now if we could do something about cell phones/texting and driving , how many deaths last year ?

6) Comment by The_Host - 09/10/2012

We can agree on lots of things DMJ. The only thing we will never see eye to eye on is government spending and government getting into business in places it was never intended. This is why I am no more Dem than I am Repub. Both parties are up to their eyeballs in hypocrisy with Dems leading the way IMO. I mean you have to admit anyone that screams TOLERANCE day in and day out and then proceeds to NOT TOLERATE anyone that doesn't agree with them sort of says it all doesn't it?

7) Comment by Whatnow - 09/10/2012

nimby?, Gee, then why not poppies and everyone could use heroin. It's a plant.

8) Comment by DMJ - 09/10/2012

This issue might be the one thing true small government conservatives and true individual liberty liberals can agree on. If only our elected representatives would follow suit.

9) Comment by The_Host - 09/10/2012

The war against weed is predicated on so many lies and untruths based on so many peoples self interests aka $$$$ it is sickening. Want to make some money Dan Claitor why not legalize it and tax it and then you could release all the people in jail for it. How much would we save then? Not to mention the costs of no longer having to pretend to enforce this farce of a law or the court costs and congestion it creates. Can anyone name something else that is considered illegal to have but that the government can profit off of at the same time? This in itself defies logic. You will NEVER stop mother nature from growing. If the pot smokers would take the time to seed the country side for a few years then what will you do government? Cut down each plant in the country? You have as much chance of stopping pot as you do the next Hurricane. NONE!

10) Comment by Spudaroonski - 08/10/2012

One more thing...Dan Claitor you are a moron. Who are these people who voted you into office?

11) Comment by Spudaroonski - 08/10/2012

@Who Cares thank you. Every night we are bombarded by commercials pushing this drug and that drug for whatever ails ya. Of course if you pay close attention they tell you real fast that these wonder drugs may cause heart attacks, stroke, liver damage, and in some cases death. Yes death. But whatever you do don't smoke that evil weed marijuana. Oh no! Everyone grab your pearls and head for the fainting couches! Heaven forbid you might get a case of the giggles and want to consume large amounts of Cheetos. Oh the horror!

12) Comment by WhoCares - 08/10/2012

Oxi Contin, Valium, Xanex, Adderal, and Codeine is legal...just sayin.

13) Comment by nimby? - 08/10/2012

Being_Stupid , Ole Smoky Moonshine Distillery , Gatlinburg, TN.

14) Comment by Being_Stupid - 08/10/2012

Legalize Moon Shine. My illegal drug of choice is White Lightning.

15) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 08/10/2012

one more time: the correct word is RE-legalize.

16) Comment by nimby? - 08/10/2012

TommyRucker , who is this "we" you speak of . on this issue I stand with my liberal friends . from a conservative view ; marijuana is not a drug , it is a plant grown from a seed , a gift from God . and what right does the government have to tell me what I can/can't do in my own house ? responsibility starts at home , it's not the job of society to be the parent ....

17) Comment by DMJ - 08/10/2012

At least let them grow hemp. You can't even get high on hemp. Trust me.

18) Comment by janiea - 08/10/2012

If this is about tax revenue than re-legalize. Many farmers out there would grow and maybe even a few more small growers would partake. Revenue would be great. I am not talking subsidizing like we do every other crop.Not to mention the ridiculous amount of misdemeanors that won't be clogging the already clogged arteries of the courts and jails. Treat it like alcohol and tobacco, they are considered legal drugs why not pot.

19) Comment by DMJ - 08/10/2012

No one is saying legalize all drugs. In fact, I think it's stupid to conflate weed with actual hard drugs. Also, no one is saying weed is completely harmless or that anyone should smoke it at any time. What we ARE saying is that with marijuana, prohibition of it is more harmful than the effects of it. It funds violent gangs, it packs our prisons, eats up our budgets, disenfranchises people, breaks up families and stigmatizes people who are generally peaceful, open-minded and kind to others. Other than gay marriage rights, this is the biggest no-brainer issue in American politics today. But...we live in Louisiana, so to those in favor of legalization: don't get your hopes up. And to those in favor of continues prohibition: you're winning. Congrats.

20) Comment by Spudaroonski - 08/10/2012

Why is marijuana illegal some ask? Here is just one example of many. This is from a nola.com article from 5/13/12 "Louisiana is the Worlds Prison Capital" It states that the hidden engine behind the states well oiled prison machine is cold, hard cash. A majority of Louisiana inmates are housed in "for profit" facilities which must be supplied with a constant influx of human beings or a 182 million dollar industry will go bankrupt. Now how disgusting is that? And that's just one example. I'm sure big pharma has an army of lobbyist fighting to keep marijuana illegal along with banks that launder drug money. You get the picture. It's not illegal because of any harm it might do to you from smoking it because study after study has shown that the risks are minimal. There was a study done not long ago that showed it may actually shrink and inhibit cancerous tumors. It is nothing short of barbaric to be locking people in cages for smoking this herb.

21) Comment by Chucky - 08/10/2012

@TommyRucker – How do you feel about alcohol ? And you should watch something else than the 1936 film “Reefer Madness” Do not legalize marijuana for the children, do it for the adults.

22) Comment by gofigger - 08/10/2012

People who worry about families being destroyed should push for a law to make most divorces illegal.

23) Comment by jedleland - 08/10/2012

i love it when this topic comes up it always brings out the big government authoritarians lurking behind all the fake small government freedom fighting christians. just get big government off my back man and let me live my own life!! but make sure that all those things my preacher tells me are bad remain illegal for everyone else just cause i disgree with it or more accurately im told to disagree with it. see: marijuana, gay marriage, opening mosques in new york, sunday alcohol sales in BR and how much of a list do you want? we can go back in time to miscegany, segregation, illegal homosexuality, women as second class citizens, and so on and so on and so on. so much for small government eh? fakers

24) Comment by boinker - 08/10/2012

Louisiana lawmakers are all looking out for lawyers interests above all because the majority of them are lawyers. Lawmakers, their friends and family are not subject to the laws they create in this corrupt state. This should not be a question of how much money who can make off what or whom. It should be a moral question. This country was created in the name of liberty. If someone tells you that you cannot pick a plant and smoke it, you aren't free. Americans should be able to do whatever they want to do as long as it does not infringe on other's freedoms or harm anyone other than the user.

25) Comment by foldgers - 08/10/2012

@NewsReader: Really? I am not saying let 5 year old kids smoke the stuff. Make it just like alcohol. 21 years old to buy it. And just like alcohol, younger kids will still get it if they want, but there is no reason to have it illegal. If you think alcohol is so safe to be legal, please do a search on that G search thing you speak of and look up annual death rates related to alcohol, also fights, arrests and kids tea bagging. Then do a search and see how many of those activities people do if all they do is smoke weed and not drink. Nuff said.

26) Comment by TommyRucker - 08/10/2012

Legalization of such drugs will adversely affect you and your family. We don't need a study from Australia or what is being done in Colorado, we need to pay attention to what is happening right in front of us, in our homes, in our families, in our communities. We know what is RIGHT. It has been diluted and placed in doubt by the destruction of the family unit that is going on in America today. We see an increase in appeasement toward children as the family unit falls apart and many of these 'champions of the drugs' are second and third generation products of these weakened family units. Drugs are NOT the answer and never will be, we need to quit trying to rationalize it by telling ourselves how great it is or could be with a legalization of these drugs.

27) Comment by TommyRucker - 08/10/2012

This is no joke and unfortunately to many legislators have joked around with government for to long. The state needs to enforce the law or get rid of it. We have to many laws on the books right now that are selectively enforced and this is at all levels of government. Go tell all the young kids and their families that his is a 'harmless' drug with all sorts of 'medical benefits', young kids that are dependent on this drug and spend a lot of time and $ in rehab. This is an abused drug as are many in our society as we are an addicted society and want/expect a 'pill' for all our problems. We are a very unhappy and ungrateful lot and now the champions are telling us that what we need is more drugs, more readily available. It won't be long before we see 'dispensers' at schools for this drug as whatever 'Little Johnny wants, he gets'. it does not matter what the adverse effects and consequence of the chemicals and drugs have on the 'greater good', it is all about ME in America today. All a bunch of screwed up kids need is more drugs-readily available and cheap. Individual addicts affect EVERYONE and EVERYONE'S lives, make no mistake about it.

28) Comment by WhoCares - 08/10/2012

This is by far the coolest thing Claitor has ever done since being in office. Lets just get this farce over with and legalize it. I'm dying to open up a cool coffee shop in Shenandoah. DMJ, this is one thing we agree on. This is why we can't let the tighty whitey wearing Michael Buble fans continue to be the face of the republican party. It's time for the nerds to step aside. I'm looking at you Connie Bernard.

29) Comment by DMJ - 08/10/2012

Just because it might not be a good idea for all people to partake at any given time, doesn't mean it should be illegal. Bacon cheeseburgers are a terrible idea, yet we can still get them...and they're fine in moderation....just like alcohol...or weed. There's a time and place. Should young kids smoke weed? Probably not...which brings up a point...the guy I bought pot from as a teenager (insert 'so that's what's wrong with you' joke here) didn't ask me for ID. He didn't care how old I was. You know?

30) Comment by gofigger - 08/10/2012

As long as the government doesn't force you to smoke it, legalize it

31) Comment by nimby? - 08/10/2012

marijuana is not a drug , it is an herb , you plant the seed , it grows .

32) Comment by LSUinVail - 08/10/2012

That New Zealand study has been debunked many times by scientific university studies across the globe. The study was done on adolescents in their developmental years. Actually this becomes an argument FOR legalization and regulation with age limits, much like alcohol. I don't know of ANYONE in the reform community who is pushing for the use of marijuana by children. Ironic, New Zealand has the highest arrest rate in the world for marijuana use yet they have the highest teenage marijuana use rate in the world. Go figure.

33) Comment by DMJ - 08/10/2012

Louisiana will be among the last to legalize...as it was with Civil Rights and as it will be with gay rights as well. This is why we need action on the federal level. Sure, it takes too long, but we'll get real change quicker than leaving it up to the yokels we elect here in Louisiana.

34) Comment by mcBR - 08/10/2012

Decriminalize it.

35) Comment by phil - 08/10/2012

****Comment Removed for Violation of Terms of Use****

36) Comment by LSUinVail - 08/10/2012

You have got to be kidding me! And ya wonder why Louisiana is the laughing stock of the country. Come on folks, quit electing these backwards idiots. I live in a small mountain town in Colorado and I can attest to the benefits of legalization. Though we haven't legalized it yet (Nov 6th ballot), since medical marijuana has been legalized we've seen millions of tax dollars fill the coffers statewide, the local street thug who also sells crack and pills to our kids has been virtually run out of town, the industry has brought thousands of jobs, our jails no longer have to incarcerate a guy with a joint, the crime rate is down...I could go on and on about the benefits of legalization. I just hate to see Louisiana lag so far behind the curve into the 21st century.

37) Comment by Whatnow - 08/10/2012

I can't even believe that our government "deals" with drug dealers. Just imagine... everyone stoned. Great, just great.

38) Comment by NewsReader - 08/10/2012

foldgers, as a counter to all those points you make, do a search using that G search engine and enter "new zealand marijuana research teens". That;s not just a flash in the pan report. That's a research conducted over THIRTY years of use. Now tell me that in this state with poor education abilities that we want our students to lose and extra few IQ points.

39) Comment by Being_Stupid - 08/10/2012

Rolfe McCollister was right back in 2008. We should have elected Lee Domingue back in 2008. He would have been the lesser of two idiots.

40) Comment by Being_Stupid - 08/10/2012

Will somebody run against Dan Claitor next election cycle? We elected an idiot by accident and nobody ran against him last election. Hopefully somebody that will restore property rights in Shenandoah will run next time. Thanks.

41) Comment by foldgers - 08/10/2012

Who is it that is keeping this drug illegal? Almost everyone I know thinks it should be legal. And honestly think about it, making it legal would do quite a few GOOD things the DAY it becomes legal. Many people would be released form prison, costing less money to go towards prisoners. Crime would drop drastically. The cartels south of the border would lose a HUGE source of income and hurting their business and most likely lower the number of murders down there. MANY MANY MANY small businesses would open and hire employees right away. Larger tobacco companies would hire more people here to compensate for the extra business... more workers, more legal businesses, more revenues from larger corporations, less money going to prisons, less money wasted on the "drug war," all mean more money for the government. So what if people can legally get high and lay on their couches at night... people can legally drink alcohol and get as drunk as they want at home. In fact people can die form drinking too much, I never heard of people dying from smoking too much pot. Put 100 random high people in a bar and put 100 drunk people in another bar. Which one would have the most fights? It almost makes too much sense to make it legal to keep it illegal, but hey, that is our government.

42) Comment by quirkmaguirk - 08/10/2012

This is why all laws need to be based on evidence proven by the scientific method instead of lawyers trying to fatten their pockets, for once I actually agree with all of the people below me. Since the Harrison Tax Act of 1914, the first federal law regulating and taxing the production, importation, and distribution of opiates, it has been refuted by experts that these laws accomplish anything productive. Stop trying to regulate morality, all it accomplishes is ruining lives and increases unnecessary spending.

43) Comment by DMJ - 08/10/2012

"Louisiana’s approach is less direct." Ha! That's a charitable way of phrasing it. We're on the losing side of this. And it's not even a partisan thing; the leadership of both parties are punting on this issue. It's ridiculous. Legalize already!

44) Comment by Chucky - 08/10/2012

First off Claitor is so wrong. His idea will only make money for his lawyer friends as each time they try to confiscate a house or earnings on tax evasion the case will be tied up in the court system, I spent 23 years in the justice system and believe that the illegality of marijuana has harmed more people than the smoking of it ever has. This law has ruined the lives of so many young people who get caught or who do not have high payed attorneys to work for them. Money aside that would be generated by the legalization of marijuana it is just the right thing to do.

45) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 08/10/2012

LOL, just another in an endless seriesof episodes of legalized highwaymen arguing over stealing other people's money. Government, ya' gotta love it.

46) Comment by stopnthink - 08/10/2012

So many problems with this I dont even know where to begin. will say two things...does this law mean it is illegal for cops to seize properties of dealers with tax stamps? wouldn't such a law possibly promote the sale of drugs and wouldn't the costs of more drug usage within towns outweigh the $3.50 per gram tax?