Ex-BR police chief's appeal set for May

Advocate file photo by BILL FEIG -- Embattled Baton Rouge Police Chief Dewayne White, left, and his attorney, Jill Craft, appear before Mayor-President Kip Holden, who is flanked by Chief Administrative Officer William Daniel, left,  and Holden's attorney, Murphy Foster, right, during a termination hearing last month. The chief made his case for why he shouldn't be fired, and then Holden decided to let him go. Show caption
Advocate file photo by BILL FEIG -- Embattled Baton Rouge Police Chief Dewayne White, left, and his attorney, Jill Craft, appear before Mayor-President Kip Holden, who is flanked by Chief Administrative Officer William Daniel, left, and Holden's attorney, Murphy Foster, right, during a termination hearing last month. The chief made his case for why he shouldn't be fired, and then Holden decided to let him go.

Ousted Baton Rouge Police Chief Dewayne White will have to wait another two months to argue his case for reinstatement before the Municipal Fire and Police Civil Service Board.

White’s appeal hearing is scheduled May 13-15, Sgt. Bryan Taylor, the board’s chairman, said on Wednesday.

The board’s scheduled meeting is set May 16, Taylor noted in an email to attorneys in the case. “This will allow for a fourth day, if needed,” Taylor wrote.

East Baton Rouge Parish Mayor-President Kip Holden fired White last month, accusing him of disregarding several departmental policies. White was accused of showing favoritism to a hire, making inappropriate transfers and shredding documents, among other things.

He appealed his termination to the civil service board last month, contending his firing was null and void because city-parish officials had not complied with the police officer’s bill of rights. The five-member panel may re-instate White with a majority vote.

“I’m really looking forward to vindicating my client’s name and letting the public know the truth about what happened and what’s happening in the Police Department,” White’s attorney, Jill Craft, said Wednesday.

City-parish officials have disputed White is entitled to civil service relief, claiming he is an unclassified employee under the local plan of government. But Murphy J. Foster III, an attorney for Holden, has said the city-parish will participate in White’s appeal and produce witnesses and evidence “to set the record straight.”

Craft said the hearing will be “like a trial, except the rules of evidence are relaxed to some extent.”

Despite the high profile of the case, there are no plans to change the venue of White’s hearing from the board’s regular meeting room inside the Fire Department headquarters on Merle Gustafson Drive, Taylor said.

The Office of State Examiner, meanwhile, has tentatively set May 22 for eligible applicants to take the civil service exam for the chief’s position.

White’s firing last month drew a mixed reaction, as a number of community leaders voiced concerns over his dismissal. Some feared his departure would disrupt the progress the Police Department has made in building rapport with residents of the city’s high-crime neighborhoods.

The Rev. Jesse Bilberry Jr., of Mount Pilgrim Baptist Church, issued a statement Wednesday expressing support for Holden on behalf of the Fourth District Baptist Association, a group of historically black Baptist churches in the Baton Rouge region. The association found it unfortunate that “some individuals” chose to make “very public statements regarding the mayor’s decision with very few facts in hand, leaving some with the impression that that represented a larger part of our community,” Bilberry said in the statement.

“Mayor Holden has shown himself to be a steady leader, capable of making difficult decisions when action must be taken for the good of our community,” the statement added. “In the past, we have seen him use a very deliberative process when hiring a chief of police, and we trust he used the same well-thought-out process when deciding that a change needed to be made.”


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (5)


1) Comment by speakthetruth - 07/03/2013

The process requires the hearing go through the civil service board before it can go to court, where it will no doubt end up. The civil service board is stacked by the mayor and PD. The board chairman is a union member and has close ties to one of the family members who is a union board member. There is an agreement between the fire department and police department to back each others votes with their own vote. The mayors appointee will obviously side against White. So lets hope the truth is able to come out and then it will go to district court. If the press wants to do some real investigative reporting check the history of the board and check the background of the board chairman. It would be easy to locate some of the past cases that were obvious rule violations but the board over ruled the chief.

2) Comment by CountryBoysCanSurvive - 07/03/2013

I hope this hearing is on TV so we can all see and hear the two forces at work and decide for ourselves who is right and who is wrong.

3) Comment by ABayouBoy - 07/03/2013

Just give the man his job back, Kip. And save the taxpayers a lot of legal fees.

4) Comment by country - 07/03/2013

Glad Mr. White is getting a hearing. I wish him luck against the regime!

5) Comment by TheAgonyOfTruth - 06/03/2013

Does anyone really think White stands a chance of a fair hearing when most of the board are Kip Holden appointees. Really now get real.