Our Views: Walkable cities shape future

Baton Rouge Mayor Kip Holden placed a priority on creating more walking and bike paths for the city during his first two terms as mayor, and we hope those goals continue to shape his third term.

This thought came to mind last week as we traveled downtown on a weekday evening and spotted many young runners using the downtown district as their route. Cheerful, energetic and attired in the best sportswear, the athletes appeared to represent a prized demographic for cities with a desire to grow and prosper: the young, educated and ambitious.

These young professionals, dubbed the creative class by urban planner Richard Florida, aren’t the only people who prize a walkable city. In increasing numbers, recent empty-nesters — parents who have raised their children and now have more disposable income — want to live in walkable cities, too. These older Americans can be great boosters of a local economy, if they can be attracted to live in a place that offers what they want.

Increasing, their wish list includes not only access to quality health care and cultural life, but walkable neighborhoods and convenient mass transit, too.

That’s one of many conclusions in “Walkable City,” a new book by planner Jeff Speck that charts the walkable cities movement.

Baton Rouge residents have a long way to go in building a community that makes walking and biking easy. Cars are the transportation of choice for most people, and sidewalks and biking paths in many parts of the city remain an afterthought. Baton Rouge is far from alone in this misguided policy, Speck tells readers of his new book.

“In the small and midsized cities where most Americans spend their lives, the daily decisions of local officials are still, more often than not, making their lives worse,” Speck laments. “This is not bad planning but the absence of planning, or rather, decisionmaking disconnected from planning.”

As a result, writes Speck, “a small number of forward-thinking cities are gobbling up the lion’s share of (young professionals) and empty-nesters with the wherewithal to live wherever they want, while most midsized cities go hungry.”

America’s large cities, for the most part, have embraced the concept of walkable neighborhoods, writes Speck. The next battleground for the cause will be in midsized communities such as Baton Rouge, he suggests. Here’s how Speck puts it:

“We planners are counting on these typical places, because America will be finally ushered into ‘the urban century’ not by its few exceptions, but by a collective movement among its everyday cities to do once again what cities do best, which is to bring people together — on foot.”


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (23)


1) Comment by phil - 07/02/2013

don_w : Don't worry, my feathers are not ruffled. However I think your statement "Our roads are underfunded, our sewer system is underfunded, our schools are underfunded, our transit system is underfunded" is not really true. We have a special tax in BR for roads, we pay taxes and fees for the $1.6 billion sewer project (that I think is out of control), there are several different millages for property taxes for public schools, and we just passed a gigantic tax for CATS . Personally I think we are way over taxed and there is just too much waste and corruption in government. I used mowing my grass as one example. I personally do not ask or expect taxpayers to build miles and miles of paths in BR so I can walk everywhere or ride a bike. Besides I doubt the average person will ever walk or ride more than about a half of a mile to get to a store etc. If you just want to ride your bike all over town, don't expect me to pay. Also I keep hearing about these young educated professionals - what about the poor uneducated people who are already n BR who have to pay all of these taxes?

2) Comment by Being_Stupid - 07/02/2013

When you deny property rights within reason, expect blight to follow.

3) Comment by Being_Stupid - 07/02/2013

The ideas promoted in the FutureBR Plan (Mixed Uses, Multi-Family, Multi-Story in walking distance to A1 Zoned Neighborhoods) are not allowed to happen under the current Planning and Zoning Bureaucraticship.

4) Comment by Being_Stupid - 07/02/2013

Lot of good ideas and entrepreneurs have proposed business and retail developments in walking distance to neighborhoods, only to have their ideas denied or be restricted to the point where building a profitable business is unfeasible. For example, somebody who wants to rezone the Southside of Perkins for a medical office, or somebody that wants to propose Mixed Office, Retail, and Multi-Residential, yet is restricted to Neighborhood Office only by the P&Z or MC. Somebody that wants to increase their parking area for a popular family restaurant.

5) Comment by nimby? - 07/02/2013

if I'm going to paint an area I clean it up 1st . crime , education , traffic , then maybe walkways/bike paths . priorities ...

6) Comment by Attila - 06/02/2013

Don-w: Comparing B. R. to Colorado Springs is comparing a mink to a skunk. Anyone who values their physical well being knows that from the Miss. river to the Amite river if you value your health you don't make left turns off of Fla blvd at night....much less on a bicycle.

7) Comment by don_w - 06/02/2013

Phil, don't get your feathers so ruffled. In many ways, I actually agree with you. Baton Rouge has lots of sidewalks to nowhere, literally and figuratively. A lot of wasted money and effort. But therein lies the problem. In the years I've been in Baton Rouge, this city never seems to do anything more than halfway. Our roads are underfunded, our sewer system is underfunded, our schools are underfunded, our transit system is underfunded. The list goes on. When my oldest son went to LSU, he lived in an apartment about two miles south of campus on Highland Road. He would have loved to ride his bike to class, but there is no bike lane, no shoulder, and no sidewalk in this area. There is, however, lots of traffic. He ended up putting his bike in the back of his truck, driving to campus, parking in the commuter lot, and then biking to class. How efficient was that? I will disagree with your suggestion that older people don't want to ride bikes or walk. People are staying much more active in later life than ever before. In fact, many if not most cross country bicycle tourists are retirees. You are sadly mistaken if you think walking around the yard or cutting the grass is all the exercise a body needs. By the way, I still cut my own grass with a push mower. I enjoy cycling not because of the exercise, but because it reminds me of all the freedom I had riding my bike as a kid. The exercise is just a side benefit. And lastly, how many people do you know who actually moved to Baton Rouge by choice? Most residents live here because the were born here and never bothered to leave, or came here because a job (or school) brought them here. I know of no one who woke up one morning and said "Gee Whiz, I think I'll move to Baton Rouge". Granted, there are many nice things about this city, but on the whole, Baton Rouge has a long way to go to be attractive to the young educated professional people that are needed to help this city prosper in the 21st Century.

8) Comment by phil - 06/02/2013

I will probably agree that paths do not necessarily bring crime into an area. I imagine most criminals want to do their crime and then jump in a car and get far away as soon as possible. However I will also add that paths along creeks behind existing homes and in some other areas might be an added security risk and might require more lighting and possibly patrols at night which adds even more to the overall costs. I think to compare this situation in BR with an existing trail that is 250 miles long in another state is comparing apples and oranges. We could build a trail in BR and call it the "high crime/murder trail" perhaps. I just think we have a lot more pressing problems in BR to spend tax money on. Heck, we can't even seem to keep a police chief with the questionable politics that goes on around here.

9) Comment by don_w - 06/02/2013

To piggyback on what DMJ said, a lot of people assume that a bike path or pedestrian walkway will bring a criminal element into an area. Most studies show the opposite effect. As more people spend time outside, more sets of eyes are trained upon the surroundings. Criminals tend to move to less observed areas. This isn't a hard and fast rule, there are lots of factors that go into the safety of an area, but the pattern is well established. I remember a case up in Kansas some years back where the communities were debating the prososal to build a 100+ mile rail-to-trails project in the area. The small town folks were afraid that crime would increase due to the influx of outsiders. What actually happened is people came from miles around to ride the trail, and while there also spent a lot of money. Many of the towns saw an economic boom. From my own experience, my wife and I rode the Katy Trail up in Missouri a few years ago. It's 250 miles long and passes through a number of small towns. Some of these towns were on the verge of complete abandonment until the trail brought a new source of income to them. Grocery stores, bed and breakfasts, cafes, all sprung up along the trail. Bicycling in this country is experiencing remarkable growth. Many local communities, not just Baton Rouge, could benefit a lot from this if they would just look at the evidence and not be so afraid of change.

10) Comment by phil - 06/02/2013

Yes, don_w : I do try to be consistent in my views. Also I have lived in BR over 60 years, I went to LSU, and I worked here over 30 years and now live in the suburbs although I used to live in the downtown area for a while. I am happy with where I live now except maybe there could be a short section of sidewalk added to connect my subdivision to a nearby shopping center. Until that happens I am content to walk on the grass like I have been doing and write comments about these other sidewalks that go to nowhere that are being built with our tax funds. When I reach 70 or 80 years old and are retired I will be so happy to be able to jump on a bike or walk a mile to the store in the 95 degree humidity and then carry all of my groceries home. Also, I imagine Colorado Springs would be a nice place for people who do not like BR to move to. I think a large engineering firm that does a lot of work in BR has a home office in Colorado doesn't it? I still walk around my yard and mow my own grass for exercise. Try it - you might find it is a less expensive way to exercise than buying bikes and building sidewalks etc.

11) Comment by nimby? - 06/02/2013

BREC parks close at dusk , why ? don_w , the Colorado Springs/Manitou Springs area is a great place for young adults , retired citizen , a different culture climate . in order for Baton Rouge to emulate such it would be necessary to bulldoze most of the area and start over . also agree as to the Tammany Trace .

12) Comment by don_w - 06/02/2013

As soon as I read this article this morning, I knew Phil would have something negative to say about it. Oh well, he's entitled to his opinion. What I found interesting was the point about retirees looking for more walkable cities to move to. My wife and I are only a few years away from retiring. I've worked in Baton Rouge for 20 plus years, but the thought of retiring here is just not that appealing. We travel a lot, so we have a pretty good idea what sort of place we'd like to retire to. Last autumn, we visited Colorado Springs (I even wrote a Letter to the Editor about our visit). There are many positive things about Colorado Springs, but the one thing that really sold us on that city was the presence of bike paths everywhere. There is no part of the city that can't be safely reached by walking or riding a bike. Phil doesn't think people around here will use such pathways. Some never will, but most Baton Rougeans will come to appreciate them the same way the folks in Colorado Springs do. And, maybe someday, people will actually WANT to relocate to Baton Rouge. One more side note; according to recent surveys of realtors, one of the most important features that young, educated, professional home-buyers are looking for today is close proximity to walking and biking trails. Just look at how prices shot up for homes near the Tammany Trace.

13) Comment by DMJ - 06/02/2013

Apparently, some people have been told to think that parks, sidewalks and bike lanes somehow correlate to crime. This, of course, is nonsense. 70805 isn't dangerous because it has sidewalks. Where do you people get this stuff from?

14) Comment by mh1949 - 06/02/2013

Let's build more nice parks with walking paths and install more sidewalks in the 70805 area.That should make sense and work nicely.

15) Comment by DMJ - 06/02/2013

Attila, please explain. This should be good...

16) Comment by Attila - 06/02/2013

Yeh buddy, that's what we need. More walkable developments with a plethora of green space so that the thugs can have even more opportunity to do their dirty work,.

17) Comment by Bighug - 06/02/2013

I do live in the suburbs, phil, but the story was about the city. I'm in the same situation that DMJ describes. If you think Baton Rouge has lots of nice wooded parks (not sports fields) then you need to see some cities that really have them. Nashville, for example, with 2,680 acres in its Warner Parks, and they are only two of several nice parks in the city.

18) Comment by DMJ - 06/02/2013

I live in a walkable neighborhood, with many conveniences just blocks away. I love it. I think everyone would too. And while such a prospect may not appeal to crotchety old shut-ins who live on the outskirts of town, I do think a more walkable city would attract (or help to retain, in our case) talent and businesses. After all, when considering to move to a city, it's hardly a selling point to learn that you have to drive everywhere you go and that, surprise, surprise... traffic is really bad. And consider tourism. When people are on vacation, they don't want to have to drive. Mayor Holden has been a great ally in this cause, but like the editorial says, we have a long way to go.

19) Comment by phil - 06/02/2013

If you live downtown and want green spaces, then maybe you should have moved to the suburbs to begin with instead of asking for parks and path etc downtown to make downtown appear like the suburbs. That is my take on possibly making some "smart choices" instead of pushing "smart growth" on everyone.

20) Comment by phil - 06/02/2013

With all of the tax money taxpayers are spending on downtown parks and green ways and paths that are not needed plus the paths along Wards Creek that hardy anyone will use and I think are dangerous when it rains, and then the long path on the Mississippi River levee that connects nothing with nothing, I suppose many taxpayers in Baton Rouge will be so broke they will have sell their cars and walk or ride bikes to get anywhere. Besides, if the government wants new sidewalks, how about build them where they will do some good. I thought downtown already had sidewalks. Besides EBR Parish is really basically a suburban area with a small downtown and it really has plenty of green spaces, BREC parks etc already anyway. How about spending money on things that are really needed like maybe those bridges we always hear about that need repairs every time a new tax is proposed?

21) Comment by SuzanneMS - 06/02/2013

A car is not my "option of choice." I don't have a choice. There are no sidewalks leading out of my neighborhood -- they only go as far as the street leading into the neighborhood on one side and a creek on the other. Even if there were, there are no sidewalks outside of my neighborhood and no bus stops. I'd have to walk or bike along the shoulder of Siegen Lane to get anywhere -- including the nearest bus stop. So, if we need a gallon of milk, we have to use the car or literally risk our lives. Any place else, Chucky, any place else.

22) Comment by Chucky - 06/02/2013

You have always been able to walk from the old state capital to the new capital from the river to the interstate, what part can you not walk ?

23) Comment by Bighug - 06/02/2013

That is a good start. In thinking of cities I consider nice to visit, it is usually the ones with lots of green space and wooded parks. The leaders of BR have seemed to lean toward more casinos to lure visitors in the past.