Letter: Much done, much to do on juvenile justice

It has been a long road for juvenile justice reform in Louisiana. There has been some improvement, but much more needs to be done.

In 2001, the Louisiana Legislature took steps to revitalize the juvenile justice system by creating the Louisiana Juvenile Justice Implementation Commission to develop a plan for reform and serve as a watchdog for progress.

In 2011, the Legislature commissioned a study to evaluate improvements made to the system over the past five years, and to issue recommendations for reform for the next five years.

The Louisiana Models for Change and the LSU Health Sciences Center Institute for Public Health and Justice were asked to perform the study with funding and support from the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation.

The JJIC recently heard preliminary study findings and early results are encouraging.

Findings indicate a decline in statewide jurisdictions utilizing costly detention and incarceration for low-risk youth as a means for corrective action. Both the state and several local jurisdictions with their own probation departments have seen decreases in low-risk youth placed on probation. This is attributed to the improvement in using best-practice screening and assessment tools for ensuring the youth who are at high risk to public safety are placed in secure settings and on intensive community supervision, versus youth who are at low risk to public safety but were in need of mental and behavioral health interventions and other services.

The study is also examining the availability and effectiveness of treatment and rehabilitative programs around the state available to youth and families and what data is available to track our successes and challenges as a state. The JJIC will receive the final study results and recommendations by the end of December.

We are fairly certain the final report will show there is still a long road ahead to truly reforming the state’s system to national standards.

Continued progress will be a challenge with the state’s current financial situation; however, it is vital we continue to implement models of reform that effectively hold youth accountable for their actions, provide for their rehabilitation, protect them from harm, increase their life chances and manage the risk they pose to themselves and to public safety.

We will need the support of the governor, the Louisiana Legislature and citizens of Louisiana in this important work.

State Rep. Walt Leger III, chairman

Juvenile Justice Implementation Commission

New Orleans


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (5)


1) Comment by Attila - 24/10/2012

By far the major contributor to juvenile law breakers is the fact that the kids no that there are no consequences to their actions...come to think of it there are a lot adults that fit that mold. Time to make breaking the law an option that has not just touchy feeley consequences, consequences that have some bite.

2) Comment by tradewinns - 23/10/2012

one of the areas our failed "justice" system really falls short is in the area of juvenile justice. instead of cracking down on juveniles and making it hard on them for illegal acts, our system does the opposite. it shows them there is nothing to be afraid (and yes they should be afraid) of in our "justice" system. want to see the results of what i have stated? just watch one of the TV programs on the subject (scared straight etc). the kids going into prison to meet with "real" criminals have no fear because they KNOW absolutely nothing bad is going to happen to them. no one is going to beat them, rape them, steal from them etc. throw them in for a week with the "bad" guys where the bad guys have immunity for any of their actions. if the kids come out as they go in, i would be shocked. i expect they would never want to go back.

3) Comment by Stephen - 23/10/2012

Nowadays here in Baton Rouge, I encounter many very disciplined children and young adults. They are well educated, motivated, and quite productive. From what I see, there are many who know how to raise healthy and happy children here in Baton Rouge. It has nothing to do with a belt. If a belt is being used, all you are doing is looking for a short cut--a short cut which serious studies (not your personal anecdote) show causes a lot more harm than good. You are being lazy when you use a belt. It is a lot of work to raise children. Try working at it.

4) Comment by rgeraldwallace@cox.net - 23/10/2012

ABayouBoy is right; juvenile apologists have just about succeeded in putting the inmates in chage. Kids are people, not angels, and they do all the things people do; if they know that no or very little punishment is forthcoming then they have no incentive to do the right thing. He "made a bad choice" instead of "He committed a crime" is a symptom of the malady.

5) Comment by ABayouBoy - 23/10/2012

I'm not at all certain what is meant by "improvements" indicated by decreased incarceration rates. The courts can grant all of the time outs, probations, and forgiveness that it wants, but the problems will still not be solved in this manner. The kids of this generation know that they will continue to dodge the bullet time and time again, and have no fear of consequences. Their bad behavior will continue until they are forced to spend time incarcerated, and only then will they learn their lesson. It is almost impossible to discipline a kid nowadays. Joint custody, broken homes, etc. If you take a belt to your kid nowadays for misbehavior, you will be the one arrested.