Our Views: Wrong tack by Romney

Amid the confusion of the protests in Cairo and Benghazi, that turned — or was incited — into a deadly attack in the latter case, there’s at least some evidence that American diplomats in Cairo were doing what diplomats ought to be doing: keeping a finger on the pulse of their host country.

The news was spreading like wildfire about a crass film from American extremists denigrating the prophet Mohammed. Having seen the loss of life that has occurred when such regrettable incidents occurred before, the U.S. embassy in Cairo issued a statement condemning “continuing efforts by misguided individuals to hurt the religious feelings of Muslims — as we condemn efforts to offend believers of all religions.”

Once protests broke out in Cairo, Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney immediately sought to exploit the situation — and shot himself in the rhetorical foot.

The embassy’s statement apparently was not cleared by the White House and was issued while the U.S. ambassador was out of the country, but its intent was clear enough: distance America and Americans from irresponsible utterances that have led to rioting and deaths before. A large trade delegation, the lives of American tourists and businessmen and friends of America from other countries were at risk if the situation got out of hand.

Shortly thereafter, the Benghazi protest turned into an armed attack that killed Ambassador Christopher Stevens and three staff members, and also apparently some Libyan security guards trying to protect the U.S. consulate.

Romney’s snap political judgment was that the Cairo statement was proof that President Barack Obama has spent his administration “apologizing” for the United States’ policies and values. This is, on its face, ridiculous, but it is believed by the extreme anti-Obama zealots — and Romney did not miss a pandering possibility.

This was a sharp political instant response, a textbook example of what political gurus teach about campaigning. But it was a case of Romney’s unwillingness to exercise the cool-headed caution that ought to govern leaders when foreign crises erupt.

“I think it is a terrible course for America to stand in apology for our values,” Romney said at a press conference, even after having had time to think this over.

We think it’s time for Romney to back down. Should the people elect him president, we can confidently predict that he will have many future occasions to bite his tongue and say what is diplomatically appropriate instead of what a sliver of anti-Obama opinion wants to hear.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (22)


1) Comment by Whatnow - 23/09/2012

Tea_Slayer, I didn't lie. You just have a different point of view of what an apology is. And I'm not the only one who thinks so. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/barackobama/5100338/Barack-Obama-arrogant-US-has-been-dismissive-to-allies.html Even papers in other countries thought so. So, no I didn't lie. Others saw what he said the same way I did, so I guess you think everyone who didn't agree with you as liars. Newt Gingrich may have his faults, but he has more experience in his little toe than Obama has in his whole body. And Gingrich doesn't have Marxist socialistic tendencies.

2) Comment by Tea_Slayer - 16/09/2012

Cat got your tongue or are you praying away your weekly allotment of sins, including lying. Just make sure you have an accurate count of your lies. I wouldnt want you to miss out on your heavenly reward. And your congressional toads comment just shows your bigotry. And Gingrich had to resign in disgrace from congress, imagine that. And yet again your small mind parrots your handlers, using the term "democrat" instead of the CORRECT "democratic". Straight from rush's mouth to your keyboard. I would say wake up to the real world, but that would be a fruitless request. Enjoy your fantasy...

3) Comment by Tea_Slayer - 15/09/2012

You did lie. "The culture of the Obama administration is to apologize first and ask questions later." At no point did anyone in the admin apologize. Newt knows it, Romney knows it. They both made ridiculous statements that only the simplest minds could be fooled into beleiving. The fact that your small mind can't comprehend that is just symptomatic of what ails the republican party and it's followers. And you don't even pretend to be a good Christian anymore, do you? Or are you one of those weekend Christians who misbehaves all week then begs for forgiveness every Sunday? So sad. And again, ou post things way above your head. I am far from narcissistic. It's almost laughable how ridiculous your posts have become.

4) Comment by Whatnow - 15/09/2012

@Tea_Slayer, Do I have to list all Democrat toads in Congress? I'll just name one for now because I don't have the time to type all day. His name is Barney Frank. And to crow about your delusional superiority only makes you seem like a very narcissistic (erotic gratification derived from admiration of one's own physical or mental attributes, being a normal condition at the infantile level of personality development) person. You and Obama are so alike and I can't understand how a narcissist can like anyone. And I do not lie and to call me one means that you are the liar. So take your smug superiority complex somewhere else.

5) Comment by krl777 - 15/09/2012

The US embassy response was entirely appropriate. “The Embassy of the United States in Cairo condemns the continuing efforts by misguided individuals to hurt the religious feelings of Muslims — as we condemn efforts to offend believers of all religions..... Respect for religious beliefs is a cornerstone of American democracy. We firmly reject the actions by those who abuse the universal right of free speech to hurt the religious beliefs of others.” [end quote] It didn't say that we will prosecute the idiots who made the film, nor should it have. It didn't apologize for the American value of free speech, nor should it have. It simply distanced the US government from the actions of free idiots. That is the proper thing to do when the mirror-image idiots in the Muslim world are preparing to go on a rampage of a sort which in the past had led to dozens of deaths and millions of dollars worth of damage in their own countries. Romney's response was vacant and vile: "“I'm outraged by the attacks on American diplomatic missions in Libya and Egypt and by the death of an American consulate worker in Benghazi. It's disgraceful that the Obama administration's first response was not to condemn attacks on our diplomatic missions, but to sympathize with those who waged the attacks.” [end quote] The Cairo embassy statement was released before the violent attack on the Libyan mission, and the Cairo embassy was never in significant danger, so Romney is an idiot for condemning the Cairo embassy for trying to tamp down the violence before it happened rather than issuing a useless fell-good outraged response, thus choosing to fuel, rather than to check, the violent response. Furthermore, the embassy statement didn't "sympathize" with those who waged the attacks -- it acknowledged the FACT that people in the Islamic world were outraged by the silly film. It attempted to thwart destructive expression of that outrage. There really are just too many idiots in the world. We don't need one of them serving as President of the US.

6) Comment by Tea_Slayer - 15/09/2012

Ok,I'll use small words so whatnow can understand. I didn't mention WHAT Gingrich said because he is a toad that even the mainstream republican party shuns. That's why you had to go to a "big" website to get that quote. Got it now? It's sad that I have to dumb down my posts so a small mind can comprehend, sheesh.

7) Comment by gvm - 14/09/2012

@Whatnow: "The culture of the Obama administration is to apologize first and ask questions later. ." Would you rather it be to kill everyone onsite EXCEPT the actual perpetrators? That's what your boy Bush did and it seems to be what Romney is advocating. The results of that course of action were disastrous. But hey, the conservative legion is chock-full of faux warriors.

8) Comment by Whatnow - 14/09/2012

@Tea_Slayer, you said nothing at all about what Newt had to say. You just stated "big-anything" websites. I guess the MSM is innocent of propaganda and doctoring quotes, right? Romney didn't fail. You dems just don't have anything else. Weak, Dems...weak.

9) Comment by Tea_Slayer - 14/09/2012

Whatnow reads right wing propaganda sites is what he should have said. Otherwise, he would not use every buzzword those hacks use. His latest is that the Obama admin "apologizes". An absolute lie, but whatnow is too ignorant to realize he is being duped. It's sad that the electorate is so easily fooled. And if whatnow had any reading comprehension skills, he would know that it wasn't just the source I was lambasting but also the speaker (Gingrich). And Romney was trying to make political hay but failed miserably. He wound up just pandering to the extreme right and alienating the moderates. But hey, that works for me.

10) Comment by Whatnow - 14/09/2012

LOL! Are you saying that you don't agree with where I got it or with what he said? The reality is going up in flames all over the Middle East. But, I guess it's Bush's fault this time, too. I'm a conservative, so I read conservative sites. Just like you read the MSM because you are not. You pick on where I got it instead of what Gingrich had to say. You guys just crack me up. You always dodge the real issues. President Obama said “That it’s important for you to make sure that the statements you make are backed up by the facts, and that you’ve thought through the ramifications before you make them.” Kinda like saying, “the police acted stupidly,” before he knew what the heck he was talking about. What a joke!! Romney was 100% right. The ambassador in Egypt is part of the administration. The culture of the Obama administration is to apologize first and ask questions later.

11) Comment by ex-louisianian - 14/09/2012

"To use a quote from Gingrich from one of the "big-anything" websites just shows how easily whatnow can be led by the nose." Especially if he can do no better than cite breitbart or any other GOP wind chamber. The US rightwing have retreated into their own version of reality and expect others to follow them.

12) Comment by Tea_Slayer - 14/09/2012

Another swing and a miss by whatnow. First, it is not OUR god. Secondly, the American people including many, many republicans saw Romney's statement as ill-timed and ill- conceived. To use a quote from Gingrich from one of the "big-anything" websites just shows how easily whatnow can be led by the nose.

13) Comment by Whatnow - 14/09/2012

Newt Gingrich said, “The American people are angry at those who kill our diplomats, attack our embassies, burn our flag, and demand we censor ourselves to avoid offending them.” http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2012/09/12/Gingrich-Attacks-Were-Coordinated-and-Directed-by-Enemies-of-U-S. I agree with everything he says. We don't do anything to them when they burn our flag and insult our country and our God. But, they commit murder and it's blamed on, of all days, 9/11, just one of dozens of anti-Islamic movies on YouTube? Yeah, sure..... But, to the Dems, what Romney said was SO much more important! A little desperate? I think so.

14) Comment by ex-louisianian - 14/09/2012

The issue with Romney (and, let's be honest -- there are manifold issues with this candidate) is that he is too weak an individual to resist any stupidity coming from the Tea Party, the GOP House, Fox News and talk radio blowhards, or the GOP defense industry lobbyists. Romney is a helpless, hapless creature of a party that already mistrusts him for religious and ideological heterodoxy. But those are his (and the GOP's) problems and not mine.

15) Comment by DMJ - 14/09/2012

Romney looked like a total amateur in this debacle. He's supposed to be the mature candidate? Please. A mature candidate wouldn't exploit a tragedy for cheap political points.... and fail at that even. This was embarrassing for Romney supporters.

16) Comment by DMJ - 14/09/2012

Romney looked like a total amateur in this debacle. He's supposed to be the mature candidate? Please. A mature candidate wouldn't exploit a tragedy for cheap political points.... and fail at that even. This was embarrassing for Romney supporters.

17) Comment by mcarter - 14/09/2012

Yes, that's the real problem in today's news. Not the fact that the white house doesn't have a clue of what's going on in the world. Egypt isn't an ally!?!?! Now off to Vegas to campaign.

18) Comment by rgeraldwallace@cox.net - 14/09/2012

Unbelievable. "The Advocate" has done it again, i.e. in spite of all information to the contrary, it has steadfastly supported the national media talking points and is trying to portray Mr. Romney as the leftist media dictates. The fact is that Governor Romney's comments are much more on the mark that anything that the administration has put out.

19) Comment by lovemykids - 14/09/2012

Admit it, Romney did shoot himself in the foot on this one. As far as the "train wreck" of foreign policy in the middle east look to Bush for an unnecessary war in Iraq.

20) Comment by arin - 14/09/2012

Talking about shoot first aim later, adv does a wonderful job at that.

21) Comment by jdk944 - 14/09/2012

Typical Advocate propaganda for the Obama Adm.!! Instead of discussing the "train wreck" of foreign policy this administration and president have created in the middle east, you play the main stream media talking points position. OH SO EXPECTED FROM YOU!!

22) Comment by bourbon-soda - 14/09/2012

Attempted repeal of the 1st Amendment by foreign riots. At best anemic defense of free speech by the administration.