Letters: Why report child abuse?

Another child, Xzayvion Riley, allegedly has been brutally tortured and beaten to death by his parents.

This is an old and too-often-repeated story for the Baton Rouge area. Yet, as with most such instances, Xzayvion’s death was completely preventable.

Law enforcement and so-called “child protective” authorities had been contacted, a file had been opened, and abuse and neglect had been documented. The people tasked with protecting this child from his own parents knew what was going on. Yet, apparently the nightmarish brutality continued and intensified, resulting in his death. We can only imagine the fear, the dread and the misery that filled this little boy’s last hours on Earth.

Now, the blame game commences. According to newspaper articles, we are to blame, for failing to report abuse. Law enforcement and protective services point to a new law requiring that people report suspected child abuse. Failing to do so may result in the prosecution of individuals who fail to make the call.

But why report abuse? Xzayvion had well-documented injuries, including a broken leg, requiring surgery. (He fell off his bed, I guess.) On his corpse, some 60 signs of old and new abuse were noted. Sixty! “Child protective services” had “interviewed” the family and had found everything to be in order. Really? Really?

I’ve called law enforcement to report actual, real-time instances of substantial child abuse. Once I called to report that a boy was being viciously beaten by his mother. You could hear the belt’s impact, from outside of their home. A deputy arrived some time later. When I described what I had witnessed and heard, the deputy told me that “the child might have deserved it”! Really?

On another occasion, I called law enforcement and reported a little girl being beaten by her mother’s boyfriend. I could hear her screams from some distance away. To my knowledge, no one came to investigate! At least, I saw no one and I was not contacted again. The “family” has since moved.

What is this little angel enduring? Is she going to join Xzayvion in death soon?

Why report abuse, when laws aren’t adequate or adequately enforced? Why report abuse, when it can take days or weeks for an investigation to commence? Why report abuse, when not enough real concern is shown for the welfare of helpless children?

The district attorney has launched a needed task force, aimed at breaking up pockets of recurring crime. What about a task force to conscientiously attack, stop and prevent the ongoing abuse of innocent children? What about taking this crime just as seriously?

Until they do, why report abuse?

wayne sanchez

mechanic

Baton Rouge


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (9)


1) Comment by InPVille - 21/06/2012

@chem: "Non-traditional families have nothing to do with child abuse." I don't know about NOTHING. But apparently not the primary indicator here. -[**]- U.S. Health And Human Services Report for the year 2010. http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm10/cm10.pdf -[**]- On Page 12 of 246 of the report: "Who abused and neglected children? For the analyses included in this report, a perpetrator is the person who is responsible for the abuse or neglect of a child. Fifty States reported case-level data about perpetratorsusing unique identifiers. In these States, the total duplicate count of perpetrators was 891,218 and the total unique count of perpetrators was 510,824. For 2010: [] More than 80 percent (81.2%) of duplicate perpetrators of children maltreatment were parents, and another 6.1 percent were other relatives of the victim. [] Of the perpetrators who were parents, more than 80 percent (84.2% were the biological parent of the victim. [] More than two-fifths (45.2% of unique perpetrators were men and more than one-half (53.6%) were women. [] More than one-third (36.3%) of unique perpetrators were in the age group of 20-29 years. More than 80 percent (84.2%) of unique perpetrators were between the ages of 20 & 49 years." -[**]- If 45.2% of the unique perpetrators were Men and 53.6% were Women, what were the other 1.2%? Children perhaps!?

2) Comment by Old Man Kensey - 21/06/2012

I don't suppose all the cuts in civil service has anything to do with it? When you reduce the number of people handling cases, things like this will happen. After all, civil servants are "people" just like the rest of us. I know people in this field-- helping children is their top priority-- but they need assistance from the state (both the government and the citizens).

3) Comment by chem - 21/06/2012

I don't understand how the authorities have a daunting task. Needle in a haystack? You go to the house and the kid is bruised and battered. Seems straightforward to me. According to all reports, the "authorities" were called to that house several times. The authorities just did not do their respective jobs. Non-traditional families have nothing to do with child abuse. The schools are limited in what they can do. The major problem is parents not being parents. In this tragic case, all the signs were there and that young boy should have been removed from that environment long ago.

4) Comment by DMJ - 21/06/2012

You report it because that's the right thing to do.

5) Comment by InPVille - 21/06/2012

Why report child abuse when there is no guarantee that the proper authorities will do what needs to be done. This should be a no-brainer. While there is no guarantee that the proper action will be taken to protect the child when valid reports are filed. There is a virtual guarantee that the abuse will continue with increasing severity if not reported. -[**]- Short answer: because it is the right thing to do

6) Comment by bourbon-soda - 21/06/2012

United Way of Milwaukee has validated the statutory rape - teen pregnancy connection with a campaign against it: http://www.jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/ad-campaign-addresses- statutory-rape-and-teen-pregnancy-rs5on7p-158701085.html . Why not here?

7) Comment by bourbon-soda - 21/06/2012

To be fair to the authorities, they are faced with a daunting problem of Bayesian statistics - the search for a needle in a haystack - and the inexorable increase in these cases associated with the devolution of mores and morals to a pre-civilizational state. One solution would be preemptive monitoring of cohabiting so-called nontraditional families, as explicated by MSNBC at www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21838575/ns/health- %20childrens_health/t/children-higher-risk-nontraditional-homes/#.T9_K- a6vdc9 but this would involve profiling. Child murder and physical abuse only tip the iceberg of school failure, teenage pregnancy (itself largely the result of the form of child abuse known as statutory rape), suicide and criminality statistically associated with - you have to love the euphemism - "nontraditional" families. It's like screening for cancer in people who refuse to quit smoking.

8) Comment by Bighug - 21/06/2012

Although most of the people who investigate child abuse are probably honest and diligent in their work, many others are not. They take the easy route and report nothing. It happens in all types of jobs.

9) Comment by Elderly Man - 21/06/2012

Thank you.