Letter: ‘Who’s to say who’s Christian?’

I had to chuckle after reading the June 9 “Facets of Faith” column in the Advocate. The headline read, “La. near top in percentage of Christians”. As it turns out, Louisiana ranked No. 4 as one of the states with the most Christians.

There’s only one problem: How do we prove that number is accurate? Unlike nearly every other label in the world, the title “Christian” is something an individual can simply claim without fear of contradiction. After all, how would we know for sure? Nearly every Christian denomination tells us, “Have faith in Jesus and you’re saved (IE: Christian)”. Some say, “Make Jesus lord of your life and you’re a Christian.”

I won’t attempt to speak for other Christians, but I frequently wonder about my own salvation. I’ve had hundreds of pastors and well-meaning people try their best to assure me that I am indeed a Christian.

How do they know? Is there a “litmus test” for Christianity? Some folks will read this and say, “Poor John, he just doesn’t understand”. To those I say, don’t spend too much time worrying about me, for I worry enough. I would, however, remind them of the words of Jesus to the “religious”: “I never knew you”.

John Singleton

equipment designer

Livingston


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (10)


1) Comment by RationalOne - 14/06/2012

Ah, yes. Bible verse time. How about this gem: "I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet." 1Timothy 2:12

2) Comment by Triple - 14/06/2012

"God enters by a private door into every individual." homage to RWE.  The burden of sin is light for those that lack spiritual conviction, but one day the burden will be great. Your response is predictable, peace. Galatians 6: 7

3) Comment by Elderly Man - 14/06/2012

Well, of course, Mormons are not Christian and they know this. Roman Catholics are not Christians but they think that they are. Methodists are not Christians even though some of them think that they are. Unitarians claim not to be Christians though they clearly are. Aside from the Left Foot Baptists, only Calvinists and Unitarians seem to be Christians. Of course, I am a Christian if you mean that I am completely agnostic, which I am.

4) Comment by DMJ - 14/06/2012

Gandhi was a true Christian....but he was Hindu. Oh well...

5) Comment by RationalOne - 14/06/2012

I've never met a true Christian. My guess is that there are very, very, very few real Christians in the world. How many "Christians" do you know who have nothing at all so they can follow Jesus? How many do you know who don't wear clothing of mixed fabric? How many do you know who routinely give burnt offerings? How many do you know who hate their families so they can follow Jesus? How many do you know who execute their kids for not honoring their parents? How many do you know who execute people for adultery or for looking admiringly at somebody of the opposite sex? How many do you know who have cut off body parts to avoid going to hell? Just sayin'...

6) Comment by nimby? - 14/06/2012

the term "good christian" , when used to describe ones self is rather frightening ........

7) Comment by DMJ - 14/06/2012

As usual, top of all the bad lists, bottom of all the good...

8) Comment by Tea_Slayer - 14/06/2012

"Ye shall know them by their fruits" I though god said he was the only judge...more religious conundrums from the "good book"

9) Comment by jdk944 - 14/06/2012

Mr. Singleton, good question!! In The Bible Matthew 7:16, KJV, it says, " Ye shall know them by their fruits." Those who profess to be Christians need to evaluate their life based on this verse and how they are or are not applying it in their walk on this Earth. I submit far to many are really not Christians today in America, that say they are!!

10) Comment by Triple - 13/06/2012

Romans 8: 38-39