Letters: Professor compliments teacher’s use of language

On the editorial page, Tuesday, April 24, there was an excellent letter to the editor by Susan Herrington, teacher, of Brusly. Ms. Herrington used the word “teacher(s)” 13 times in her short letter, including her signature, and not once did she use the more pretentious and self-serving term “educator.”

I read a lot of what is written about the problems of educational reform in Louisiana, including the letters to the editor.

After 35 years as a college professor, reading and evaluating papers, it is easy to spot insincerity.

That is why I quit reading any letter or document as soon as I see the word “educator.”

The time-honored word “teacher” connotes someone who provides a valuable service, likely unrequited, to another human, usually a student. “Educator” is merely a cold professional term most often used only to impress.

The points Ms. Herrington made in her letter are cogent and worthy of close consideration.

Her inclusion of a mathematical simulation of “value-added” education was an excellent form of satire on the educational establishment. I hope someone in the education bureaucracy is listening.

Malcolm Wright

retired engineering professor

Baton Rouge


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (6)


1) Comment by Bouncer - 04/05/2012

Sorry....make that "I would go one step further....."

2) Comment by Bouncer - 04/05/2012

I am not especially fond of the term "educator" either, but I recognize it as the teachers' attempt to give themselves a label that has a snappy ring to it. would go one step further with the argument, however. After over 20 years of teaching at LSU, one of the things that I have noticed is that "professors" are extremely conscious of rank. If the term "teacher" is so time-honored and worthy of veneration, then why does Mr. Wright insure that he signs his letter "retired engineering professor" as opposed to "retired engineering TEACHER"? The reason is that the academy encourages such semantic hair-splitting, and it also sets up a clear pecking order, where some "teachers" in the institution imagine themselves as operating on a more lofty plane than others.

3) Comment by Elderly Man - 03/05/2012

DMJ. I suppose you have a point but I appreciated (liked) both letters.

4) Comment by Elderly Man - 03/05/2012

DMJ. I suppose you have a point but I appreciated (liked) both letters.

5) Comment by DMJ - 03/05/2012

Considering that "teach" and "educate" are synonyms, I'd have to say that this letter seems unnecessary. Who cares if a teacher calls themselves an educator? They're not lying. Teaching is educating, is it not?

6) Comment by Elderly Man - 03/05/2012

The professor makes a fine compliment to a well deserving writer. Thank you.