Our Views: Benedict exit historic

As leader of the Catholic Church, Pope Benedict XVI has proven an ardent defender of church tradition. But in announcing his resignation, Benedict has broken with centuries of precedent, setting an example that could shape the pontificates of many future popes.

In announcing plans to step down later this month — a move he said was necessary because of his advanced age and declining health — Benedict became the first pope to resign in 600 years. For hundreds of years, popes have ended their pontificates by dying in office. In opting to leave the papacy while he is still alive, Benedict will no doubt make it easier for future popes to exercise the same option.

In the 21st century, a pope’s physical condition is difficult to conceal. The modern media age means increased scrutiny on pontiffs, and gone are the days when a pope could work largely out of public view.

The modern papacy also brings physical demands that would tax a 20-year-old. John Paul II, Benedict’s immediate predecessor, traveled extensively. Because of that globe-trotting by the legendary pontiff, today’s Catholics expect to see their pope up close. Meeting such expectations can be especially difficult for an elderly cleric, and Benedict will soon be 86 years old.

In leaving the papacy, Benedict has sounded a note of change in a church where change tends to come very slowly. Whether more changes are ahead will depend on Benedict’s successor.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (13)


1) Comment by Michael Gary Scott - 16/02/2013

The mainstream media including this paper has been an opponent of Benedict sice his days as Cardinal Ratzinger, so this editorial rings hallow. Think God we had a man to follow in the footsteps of John Paul the Great, we will think God for his succesor. The media will be disapponted when the candidate they are pushing as the papal Barak Obama will still be a cardinal after the conclave, fortunately the conclave does not have the warped non-Christian values of the mainstream media.

2) Comment by legrand - 16/02/2013

Historic or not, as a disaffected Catholic, I will not miss pope Nazinger. Perhaps the Catholic Church should try to appoint a younger, open-minded cardinal to the papacy to lead it to the 21st century and bring people like me back to the Church, but that is probably just a dream. We will get a pope hand-picked by Nazinger; do not expect any push out of the middle ages any time soon.

3) Comment by Bouncer - 15/02/2013

Perhaps one of the reasons he is stepping down is that he might be feeling guilt over enforcing Church policy regarding confidentiality of internal investigation into charges of molestation. As far as his being a member of the Hitler Youth, well, he was pressed into service when he was 14, as required by German law at that time. My understanding is that he was not a rabid supporter of Hitler. It was the law. He complied, as all 14 year olds did. I do not have any strong feeling about this man one way or the other, being non-religious. I think that he did the job he was selected to do, and one of those job responsibilities is to take care of the Church. As far as any allegations against him, who really knows?

4) Comment by phil - 15/02/2013

DMJ, even I am surprised at your comment, at least the last part.

5) Comment by hemogoblin - 15/02/2013

Sean Cardinal O'Malley might make a good Pope

6) Comment by hemogoblin - 15/02/2013

DMJ-Actually 8.6's gesture was full of meaning-wishing you well and irritating you at the same time.

7) Comment by DMJ - 15/02/2013

Thanks for that totally meaningless gesture that you only did to inflate your already overblown sense of self-righteousness.

8) Comment by 8point6 - 15/02/2013

May God bless dmj.

9) Comment by DMJ - 15/02/2013

Benedict was a Hitler Youth. He also knew about multiple pedophile priests and actively coverred it up. Bless him, you say? No. F him.

10) Comment by phil - 15/02/2013

The Pope will leave at his decision, and long live the Pope. 8point6 already said what I would add.

11) Comment by 8point6 - 15/02/2013

Pope Benedict, may God continue to bless you.

12) Comment by 8point6 - 15/02/2013

I remember seeing Pope John Paul II in New Orleans in the '80's. This pianist played the most beautiful rendition of "Amazing Grace" I had ever heard. I don't know if his name was Roger or Robert Cole/Kole I've searched the internet but, haven't found the video of him playing at that particular event. I might be wrong on the name. I think WBRZ had televised it.

13) Comment by rgeraldwallace@cox.net - 15/02/2013

Who said all "change" is good? The Pope is doing what he's doing as a personal matter, not something for progressives to jump on as another tool to use in their ongoing effort to tear down something they don't control or intimidate.