Catholic school enrollment drops

Show caption
Catherine Threlkeld / 00033549a
Advocate staff photo by CATHERINE THRELKELD -- Enrollment in Catholic schools has declined since 2000 in the Diocese of Baton Rouge, the Archdiocese of New Orleans and statewide.

Echoing a national trend, enrollment in Catholic schools has fallen 18 percent statewide during the past 13 years, figures show.

Enrollment has dropped 9 percent in the Diocese of Baton Rouge since 2000 and has fallen 25 percent in schools that make up the Archdiocese of New Orleans, in part because of population losses after Hurricane Katrina struck in 2005.

The numbers were compiled by the National Catholic Educational Association, which is a voluntary association of educators and institutions in Arlington, Va.

The national drop in enrollment is 23 percent.

Theories for the drops vary, including rising costs of tuition, migration away from central cities where Catholic schools often thrived and smaller-sized families.

A total of 81,121 students attend schools in the state’s seven dioceses, down from 98,510 in 2000, according to NCEA figures.

Enrollment totals 15,201 students in the Diocese of Baton Rouge compared to 16,784 at the turn of the century.

Melanie Verges, superintendent of schools for the diocese, said a wide range of factors have contributed to the drop, which she noted is well under the national slide.

Verges said economic concerns, the growth of public magnet and charter schools, and geographic shifts account for some of the losses.

Jan Lancaster, superintendent of the Office of Catholic Schools for the Archdiocese of New Orleans, said the number of her schools has dropped from 102 to 85 in the past 10 years or so.

Population drops after Hurricane Katrina are part of the reason, Lancaster said, which means fewer kids to fill the schools.

“We see that from the numbers,” she said.

Enrollment in the archdiocese is 38,280 compared with 51,247 in 2000, according to NCEA figures.

Officials of Xavier University Preparatory School announced on Wednesday that the 98-year-old school would close at the end of the academic year. Enrollment drops appear to be one of the reasons for the closure.

Xavier is not one of the archdiocesan schools.

Sister Dale McDonald, director of public policy and research for the NCEA, said the national decline stems in part from costs to attend the schools.

McDonald said that, over the past decade, elementary school tuition rose 69 percent nationally, and secondary schools’ tuition rose by 136 percent.

“Many factors account for that: increasing operating costs related to costs and benefits, reduced enrollment which causes further tuition increases to meet operating expenses,” McDonald wrote in an email response to questions.

Average elementary school tuition for students in the Diocese of Baton Rouge is $4,160, said Danny Loar, executive director of the Louisiana Conference of Catholic Bishops.

Average high school tuition is $7,198.

McDonald, who said she could not discuss specific diocese enrollment drops, said other factors help explain the national trends. “Today, church attendance is down and parents may not see the value in faith-based education,” she wrote.

“Also, there is strong competition from charter schools in many areas that are free and attract parents who often consider them a “free” private school because they often resemble Catholic schools in many aspects,” McDonald said.

Cardinal Timothy Dolan, archbishop of New York, touched on the subject in a recent column in The Wall Street Journal during Catholic Schools Week. “It is sometimes hard to understand why enrollment has dropped,” Dolan wrote.

“After all, even the enemies of Catholic education — and, sadly, there are some who wish our schools would disappear altogether — grudgingly admit that Catholic schools are unparalleled in providing a first-rate education that also emphasizes character and virtue,” Dolan wrote.

Not all schools have seen enrollment dips.

John Bennett, principal of St. Aloysius Catholic School, said his school has grown so much that it often requires four sections per grade, up from three previously.

Enrollment is 1,169 students for the school, which is in Southdowns.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (5)


1) Comment by teacherguy - 25/02/2013

This topic is more complicated than many of you have given it credit for. I think that the grand scheme is to turn public education over to private vendors...and the voucher schemes, evidenced by not demanding much accountability...is an effort to revive those Catholic school populations (and other church schools). I disagree with Vernonbrew22 when he says that inner city families are actively looking for options to move their children out of failing public schools (some, yes, but most, no) because I cite the low percentages of families applying for those options...those parents want their communities to shape up...they KNOW their school is a reflection of the community! They also know that if they take their good kids out of those schools, there would be no hope for the future of the community while they would cripple their child's social ability to be better than their environment. In the economic recession, more families have turned to public education because of its affordability and have abandoned these Catholic schools. Also, in the White Flight due to the desegregation lawsuits...many families chose, like redavaw1 below, to move to outlying districts (Livingston, Ascension, Zachary, etc.) choosing to invest private tuition money into a home instead...which makes more financial sense in the real estate realm, not as selfish as Notauser accuses. It doesn't help that the Catholic church has taken some moral hits from SOME of its priests. Look for these school sites to be converted into charter schools that will skim every dollar they can from operating costs to bank profits: hiring uncertified, inexperienced teachers, outsourcing guidance/library costs, and forcing students to bring a lunch from home. It is OBVIOUS this plan will be better for LA's poor kids...

2) Comment by Notauser - 24/02/2013

The reason for the drop is that parents do not feel they can afford the tuition combined with a reduction of religious affinity. The two are probably somewhat related. As my parents generation was called the greatest generation, my generation will likely be called the worst generation. Baby-boomers do not feel obligated to try to make the world better for their kids and those kids have never even imagined such an obligation. Starting with the boomers each generation has been more selfish. They have made sure they have every entitlement from social security to Medicaid and beyond. The fact they have made debt slaves of future generations doesn't concern them. They live on borrowings in their personal lives also. After paying all the interest on their credit cards and car loans they have less spending money since a lot of their income goes to the bank. Given the choice of spending that limited income on their kids or on the newest igadget they pick the igadgets. That selfish view is a characteristic of Catholics in today's society as much as anyone else.

3) Comment by twinkie1cat - 24/02/2013

Maybe, in addition to the steep costs, parents are tired of schools that force conservative religion down the throats of their children, especially when that church is known to have some of the worst "logs" in their own eye, child molestation, and generally not only refused to do anything about it, but tried to cover it up. Perhaps too, the lack of diversity and screening out and denying admission to children with special needs is a factor. I mean really, in today's world would you want your child to go to school only with kids that are just like him????? Discipline in a Catholic school does not mean the child gets help with his problems. What it means is they are told they are bad and kicked out. Used to be they were beaten, but I don't know if they still do that. Also the parochials underpay their teachers and don't have to hire certified teachers. Maybe the parents want stability in and a professional teaching staff that they used to be able to get in public schools before Jindal started abusing the teachers. And just maybe, a lot of American Catholics are just sick of their church and looking for relationship with Jesus Christ to replace rituals and ceremonies .

4) Comment by Vernonbrew22 - 24/02/2013

All private schools have the upside of controlling discipline and adjusting curriculum to fit the needs of the individuals. Problem is that many inner city families have no option but to pay their weekly ransom at mass and pay university-like fees and tuition in order to get a decent education opportunity for their kids. The alternative is to move to a suburb or send your kids where they could be raped or simply rot. There are some good public schools in the outlying areas but these places gave to reach out to all. Eventually, bad weeds may enter the fruitful garden. Most experts and test scores and college graduation percentages have proven an increasing gap between private haves versus public have-nots (minus the few exceptions). But it comes at a huge expense and I vow to one day change my monetary weekly donations to a more organic substance, once my kids are out of threatening reach of the molesters and so called noble greedy clergy. It is real hard to pay 11k for high school.

5) Comment by redavaw1 - 24/02/2013

My family and I moved out of the area so we could send our children to public schools. It's pretty well known that public schools have far surpassed private catholic schools in education. Seems like they are trying to make up for that by having the children get lap tops ect. which adds to the education costs but doesn't increase the quality of what is being taught. You can also see a serious decline in catholic membership which would add to the decline in school attendance. Basically The Catholic Church is not keeping up with the times and has made membership too difficult and expensive on the average family. Middle class families use to be the bread and butter of the schools. Now even the average family can't afford tuition. I'd be interested to know how many students aren't even from catholic families. Use to be there were just 1 or 2 per grade, but I would bet that has increased dramatically because non-catholic's want to keep their children out of the public school system in EBR and the catholic schools need to fill seats. My 2 children went to non catholic schools and have done very well. They are both in college making 3.0 or better every semester and received TOPS. I'm very proud to say they went to Livingston Parish Schools instead of EBR Catholic Schools. Plus I didn't have to worry about my son being an alter boy at a church!