EBR school buses to get cameras

Show caption
Richard Alan Hannon / 00030448a
Advocate staff photo by RICHARD ALAN HANNON -- Thirty East Baton Rouge Parish school buses have a series of cameras installed both outside and inside. This bus, parked at the school system's Transportation Office in Baton Rouge Thursday, has three passenger monitoring video cameras like this one. The School Board on Thursday agreed to expand from the number of buses outfitted with the live-view monitoring system from 30 to 80.

Fourteen months after deciding to test traffic cameras on 30 school buses, the East Baton Rouge Parish School Board agreed Thursday to add cameras to 50 buses at a time until they are on all 650 of the school system’s buses.

The board, however, asked for a report after every 50 installations and wants the school system to use some of the money raised from traffic ticket fines to pay for a public information campaign.

The vote to expand the pilot program was 10-0. Board member Jill Dyason was absent.

The cameras are largely meant to catch motorists who speed past when a bus stops to pick up or drop off children, but also are being used to monitor student behavior and driver performance.

The call for an incremental approach of putting cameras on 50 buses at a time and to provide regular reports to the board was in response to concerns raised by School Board member Craig Freeman.

“Why would we expand from a pilot when we don’t have concrete data on how we’ve done up until now?” Freeman asked.

The idea of using some of the money from traffic ticket fines for a public information campaign was in response to concerns by board member David Tatman and Evelyn Ware-Jackson.

“If we’re just writing people tickets, we’re not making anything safer,” Tatman said.

Ware-Jackson said she suspects many drivers, like her, haven’t taken a license test in years and are fuzzy about some of the rules.

“I couldn’t tell you how many feet you need to stop behind a bus. I just know you need to stop,” Ware-Jackson said.

The traffic cameras are being supplied and installed by a Harahan-based company called Force Multiplier Solutions, formerly known as Busguard. The company has more than 2,000 bus cameras in operation, most of them in Dallas and Jefferson Parish.

The company pays for all costs, including the monitoring of the video, in return for collecting 70 percent of the ticket money. The school system receives 20 percent, and the Sheriff’s Office, which has to decide whether the evidence is strong enough to issue a ticket, receives 10 percent.

Under the city-parish’s ordinances, the cost of driving through a stop by a school bus as it is picking up or dropping off children in East Baton Rouge Parish is $300. Drivers who contest their tickets must do so through city-parish government.

Catherine Fletcher, chief business operations officer, said the school system so far has received two checks that total a combined $7,031, or 20 percent of the proceeds. That means at least 100 tickets have been issued so far generating at least $35,000 in revenue.

School officials said the new bus traffic cameras would have raised more money if not for a slow installation process.

At a Nov. 1 School Board meeting, Casey Ponder, a regional operations manager for Force Multiplier Solutions, detailed problems that his company had in getting the pilot program up and running. He said the problems started at the first meeting he had in fall 2011 with then Transportation Director Bill Talmadge.

“He told us the system was forced upon him, that it was too sophisticated, and Baton Rouge was not ready for a system as sophisticated as ours,” Ponder said.

Ponder said that in the following months, Talmadge and his staff were not helpful in making sure his company had access to the buses so the cameras could be installed.

“It wasn’t until the summer that we were able to finish the install of 30 buses,” Ponder said.

Ponder also said this company couldn’t get access to the buses to maintain the cameras.

Talmadge has retired since the problems came to light, and the system’s purchasing director, Gary Reese, was tapped to become interim director of transportation since mid-October. The school system has placed ads seeking a new permanent transportation director.

Domoine Rutledge, general counsel for the school system, said relations with the company are much better now.

“There were some challenges,” Rutledge said. “Some of those were staff-driven. Those have been addressed.”

After Thursday night’s meeting, Ponder said his company hopes to quickly to expand the cameras to the school system’s entire fleet. He said the company has already purchased more than $4 million worth of camera equipment and is ready to start installing them immediately.

Rutledge said the city-parish government is encouraging the school system to add new bus cameras slowly so it can ramp up to process the increased number of tickets it will likely be receiving.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (9)


1) Comment by phil - 22/12/2012

Do the math. How many tickets will have to be given out at $300 each for this company to break even just on the $4 million for the camera equipment? I personally think they are going to have to be very aggressive in handing out tickets to even break even on this deal. What's up with this? Follow the money - again?

2) Comment by Bouncer - 21/12/2012

Yes, Ivy, the cameras are also designed to cut down on the incidences of misbehavior. I don't think it's currently possible to fine the parents if their brats misbehave, though. :) I simply meant that fines for parents are as good of an idea for generating revenue as fines for the cars ignoring the bus's STOP sign.

3) Comment by tradewinns - 21/12/2012

i have been a proponent of fines on parents of unruly students for years now. you cain't get a politician to even think about it as it may cost the politicians votes and the idea is politically uncorrect. it would work! you would have to make the fines mandatory, no exceptions for fiscal standing. poor, middle class, rich everyone pays either up front or accounts/wages seized, or benefits withheld. that's the only way order will be restored.

4) Comment by Ivy - 21/12/2012

@Bouncer: I thought that WAS the purpose of cameras on buses. Lord knows they would rake it in the first months of the school year until the parents realized cameras don't lie and started taking more responsibility for their children.

5) Comment by Bouncer - 21/12/2012

If you really want to jack up revenue from the cameras, also begin to issue $300 tickets to parents whose children habitually misbehave on the bus. After a few of those, I imagine those buses would be as serene and quiet as a graveyard. Either the troublemakers would settle down, or their parents would have to find alternate means of getting them to and from school. The same thing applies to parents of kids who habitually cause trouble at school. Levy some hefty fines against them, and you would see trouble diminish significantly.

6) Comment by phil - 21/12/2012

I think we also need to install cameras and microphones in the offices of all politicians who come up with these kind of ideas. The public can then collect fines every time a politician is caught doing something questionable. Heck we might even be able to eliminate taxes that way.

7) Comment by tradewinns - 21/12/2012

freeman is correct on one thing, why go ahead if you don't know if it is working or not. besides the money, there is the riders behavior. if a rider does not follow the rules and direction of the driver, what is to happen to correct their behavior?

8) Comment by SeeingSpots - 21/12/2012

I like how this article is about raising money and not about the safety of the children.

9) Comment by Being_Stupid - 21/12/2012

We are watching you.