RSD to run Istrouma High

Progress not enough to stop takeover

Istrouma High School is being taken over this summer by the Louisiana Department of Education and placed under new management, the interim superintendent of the East Baton Rouge Parish school system said Tuesday.

Interim Superintendent Carlos Sam said Patrick Dobard, superintendent of the state-run Recovery School District informed him of the impending takeover during a meeting they had two weeks ago.

Dobard confirmed the takeover.

“We just haven’t seen the type of transformation that would warrant us staying with the current management agreement,” Dobard said.

The takeover affects about 1,000 students in grades 9 to 12, including about 225 who attend EBR Lab Academy housed on the Istrouma campus. Istrouma is joining seven other former East Baton Rouge Parish schools the RSD took over and placed under new management in 2008 and 2009.

Dobard said the state does not plan to take over any other East Baton Rouge Parish schools besides Istrouma this go-around.

On April 16, Sam and a handful of top administrators met with faculty and staff at Istrouma High, as well as their peers at EBR Lab, to inform them of the likely change in management.

Human Resources staff followed up Monday, providing information to teachers and staff. The School Board is expected to do little if any hiring this summer and may end up having to lay off some employees to plug a large budget shortfall, estimated recently at $28 million to $33 million.

More disruption is likely in the near future.

At 11 a.m. Thursday, RSD is holding a news conference at Capitol High School to lay out details of a proposed “achievement zone” that is expected to include roughly 20 north Baton Rouge schools. Details so far have been sketchy.

Sam said he has yet to see a plan of what’s going to happen with this proposed “achievement zone,” which would include schools the RSD runs or oversees, as well as ones the parish school system runs.

Sam said he’s planning to hold a community forum at Istrouma High soon to explain what’s happening.

“We’ll wait on the announcement on Thursday, so we can have a better idea of where the state is going with the achievement zone,” Sam said.

Past RSD takeovers in Baton Rouge were very disruptive, involving wholesale and repeated changes in leadership and teachers. Less than half of the students in those schools previously remained.

Dobard said the takeover of Istrouma High and creation of the achievement zone need not be disruptive as long as RSD and the school system work with each other.

“It’s a matter of what spirit of cooperation they want to work in,” Dobard said.

Sam said he opposes the Istrouma takeover. He noted that the high school had a very successful year in 2010-11.

Istrouma High improved its school performance score 9.1 points that year, though it’s still considered an “F” school by state accountability standards. Istrouma would have to grow at a much faster rate this year to escape that label. Sam said he expects more growth this school year, though not necessarily that much.

“Based on preliminary projections, we think they are going to make growth this time around as well,” Sam said.

Dobard responded that despite the growth, more than 60 percent of Istrouma students remain below grade level.

Istrouma High Principal Linda Lewis is no stranger to takeover. She was principal at Capitol High School for several years until it was taken over by the state in 2008. From 2005 to 2008, Lewis ran the high school’s girls-only school — an experiment since abandoned — and the school came close to exiting corrective action before the state took it over.

Now, Lewis said she’s feeling déjà vu.

“The first time I really took it hard,” she said. “The thing is bigger than me. I’m not taking it personally.”

Lewis said the school is filled with tough-to-teach students, more than a third of them a year or more behind their peers and a quarter of them identified for special education services.

Lewis said she feels her faculty and staff, which number about 90 people, have complied with the school’s management agreement with the state struck in 2009.

“We feel like we’ve jumped through the hoops to do what the state wanted us to do and what the district wanted us to do,” she said. “It was a daunting task.”

Lewis said about two-thirds of her teachers are tenured, meaning the school system is obligated to place them somewhere else in the school system, but the rest will have to find new jobs.

Lewis said a couple of her teachers attended an RSD teacher fair held Saturday at Capitol High and filled out applications for jobs at the new Istrouma High. They were interviewed by Robert Webb, former principal at Belaire High in Baton Rouge and current principal at Slaughter Community Charter School.

Dobard acknowledged that Webb, a graduate of Istrouma High, will be the next principal at his alma mater.

EBR Lab’s future is uncertain. The small high school was started in 2007 with much fanfare, modeled after Bronx Lab School, a charter school in New York City founded by Baton Rouge native Marc Sternberg.

The school system nearly closed EBR Lab last year. Sam said he will have a recommendation about EBR Lab before a special School Board meeting May 2 to consider possible budget cuts.

“We have to make a decision whether we move EBR Lab or close EBR Lab,” Sam said.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (7)


1) Comment by GrammarDame - 26/04/2012

Excellent points have been made here. Is anybody listening? The same figure-juggling is going on with the value-added scores for teachers. In the pilot program, teachers with National Board Certification, whose students all passed the state tests, and who received excellent site evaluations are getting NEGATIVE scores using the state DOE's voodoo math calculations! The media are not serving the public interest by publishing press releases. When is someone going to get to work and follow the money so the public can see what is really going on here?

2) Comment by iluvbtr - 25/04/2012

@fightintraffic: As I previously mentioned, I don’t put much credence in the SPS scores, other than the fact that they are an accurate predictor of the percentage of low-income students attending the school. However, I think it’s important to note that 67.9% students at EBR Lab are below grade level vs. 62.2% below grade level at Istrouma. The point is that if the LDOE is going to use the scores in order to takeover schools they need to look in the mirror. By their own measures, the state-run RSD is a complete failure. Our children can't wait. Who will takeover the RSD schools; the failed charter operators?

3) Comment by Marc - 25/04/2012

So let me get this straight... Istrouma's school performance score grows 9.1 points under local control last year, but a huge state bureaucracy says that isn't enough and thinks it can do better... Only in Louisiana would something this asinine be considered. I'd suggest that the Louisiana Department of Education needs a take-over by somebody with a little sense.

4) Comment by fightintraffic - 25/04/2012

School performance scores are calculated for high schools based 70% on a school's assessment index and 30% on a school's graduation index. EBR Lab's SPS from 2011 of 58.4 is based 100% on an assessment index and includes no graduation data because EBR Lab did not graduate its first class until May of 2011. (Graduation data lags one year behind so that 2011 data isn't included in SPS until 2012.) Istrouma's SPS, however, does include graduation cohort data as 30% of the school's score. In 2011, EBR Lab's cohort graduation rate was 87.1 and Istrouma's was 43.7. It is a little unfair to compare two schools based solely on SPS when those scores are not calculated the same way. In 2012, the graduation index will, for the first time, be included in EBR Lab's school performance score.

5) Comment by iluvbtr - 25/04/2012

@BRmoderate: Keep in mind that the only meaningful information we can derive from School Performance Scores (SPS) is the student populations' level of poverty (free and reduced lunch percentages). See http://educatorsforall.org/blog/2012/3/8/why-schools-fail-or-what-if-failing-schoolsarent.html. With regard to your question, the LDOE website (http://www.louisianaschools.net/resources/community/my_schools.aspx) shows an SPS of 58.4 (F-) for the East Baton Rouge Laboratory Academy with 32.1% of students performing at or above Grade-Level. Istrouma High School received a baseline SPS of 55.6 with 37.8% of students performing at or above Grade-Level. However, there appear to be inconsistencies in SPS reporting in the variety of reports available from LDOE. Other LDOE reports indicate Istrouma received a 2010 baseline SPS of 53.9 and a 2011 baseline SPS of 55.6; East Baton Rouge received a 2010 baseline SPS of 65.3 and a 2011 baseline SPS of 58.4. A letter grade of F is assigned to schools with SPS scores less that 64.9. FYI--the grading scale for letter grades is set to change for 2012.

6) Comment by BRmoderate - 25/04/2012

How do students in EBR lab compare to istrouma? I am curious to see if EBR Lab is in itself a "F" school

7) Comment by iluvbtr - 25/04/2012

This is very interesting. Istrouma is showing positive growth trajectory of 17% over the prior year. The RSD currently runs 7 schools in the Baton Rouge area. Of those schools posting scores on the Louisiana Department of Education’s web site, none show a percentage growth higher than Istrouma. 6 of the 7 (86%) Baton Rouge RSD schools are failing F Schools. The other is a D school and is on the state’s academic watch list. All but one of the Baton Rouge RSD schools posting performance scores on the LDE website have scores lower than Istrouma. Istruoma outperforms the best Baton Rouge RSD school by 28% and the Baton Rouge RSD school by 49%. The RSD, the second worst school district in the state, wants to take over Istrouma? Is this in the best interest of the children. Will the parents have a choice in this decision?