GOP gaining in state

Show caption
/

Party registration not showing trend

While Republicans have been gaining Louisiana election victories, there’s been no corresponding big shift in Republican voter registration, state election records reveal.

Increasing numbers of white voters have left the Democratic Party in the last decade but many have chosen an independent or other party option instead of moving to the GOP, according to state records.

A decade ago, 52 percent of white voters were Democrat, 30 percent Republican and 18 percent in the other party column.

Today, slightly more whites are opting for Republican party registration than Democrat — 38 percent to 37 percent. But 25 percent of white voters aren’t aligned with either of the major political parties.

Political analysts and pollsters say the open primary election system, where all candidates regardless of party are on the same ballot, has a lot to do with the GOP victories.

There’s no real need for Democrats to switch to Republican when it comes to the voting booth and no compelling reason to align with a party either for some voters, they said.

“You don’t have to choose a side. It’s easy to go ‘no party’ because there’s no sanction,” said LSU associate professor of political science Robert Hogan.

“The vote is for the person, not the party as people always say, but in reality a lot of people registered independent aren’t no party,” Hogan said.

Hogan and political-poll analyst Bernie Pinsonat said more of those white no-party voters are tending to vote Republican as well as some white Democrats.

“A poll question we always ask is, ‘No matter how you are registered, who do you tend to vote with?’ ” said Pinsonat. “It used to be 33-34-35 percent Republican. Now the number of people who say they tend to vote Republican … approaches 50 percent.”

Pinsonat said some of that propensity in more recent times has had to do with Democrat President Barack Obama as well as Obama administration policies on energy and health care that create political problems in Louisiana.

“But there’s no great urge or urgency for them to change parties,” he said.

“There has been this (voting) shift, but it doesn’t mean it’s going to be here forever because there’s been no corresponding change in registration by white Democrats over to Republican,” Pinsonat said. “If there’s a silver lining for Democrats, it’s that.”

Long-term and short-term forces are at play, said Kurt Corbello, an associate professor of political science at Southeastern Louisiana University who does polling.

“While some voters have realigned from Democrat to Republican, at least to some degree, Louisiana voters have been affected by the same (party) de-alignment pressures felt for decades now by voters all across the country,” Corbello said.

“Clearly, the Louisiana electorate continues to be in transition,” he said.

As whites are less and less likely to vote for a Democrat, there’s been a “hardening of the electoral performance” among black voters, said Shreveport political analyst Elliot Stonecipher, who monitors polling and census data.

Ideological issues continue to keep black voters aligned with the Democratic Party, Stonecipher said.

Black voters make up 30 percent of the state’s 2.8 million registered voters — 80 percent of them are registered Democrats, according to state election’s records. Today, they make up slightly more than half of Louisiana’s registered Democrats, a historic event.

Just ten years ago, white voters made up about 60 percent of Democratic Party registration. Today, their numbers have dropped to just below 50 percent — just like statewide Democratic voter registration.

The so-called Reagan Democrats changed party registration to Republican, said Stonecipher, referring to moderate to conservative Democrats who aligned with President Ronald Reagan.

“That’s not going to happen here. They are going to continue to vote more and more Republican and not change (parties) if they are white and over 50,” Stonecipher said.

“People still feel comfortable being a Democrat although they may vote Republican,” Pinsonat said.

“Other race” voters — a category that includes Hispanics and Vietnamese — aren’t signing up in droves with either major party.

Nearly half of “other race” voters are registered with “other parties.” If they do opt for a major political party, it’s more likely Democrat than Republican.

Outside of Florida, Hispanic voters tend to be Democrat largely because of national issues such as immigration, Hogan said.

“As long as the Republican Party continues to exude any type of elitism, and they still do, as long as they are still the Republican Party country club elite, you can imagine minorities would have a natural tendency to go the other way,” Stonecipher said.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (32)


1) Comment by Scrooge - 30/08/2011

After thinking about it, julwood's post has to be satire

2) Comment by Scrooge - 30/08/2011

julwood "Therefore, if you are not for what the Tea Party stands for, then you are an enemy of the country and should be treated as such." Seig Heil! Ein volk, ein reich, ein Fuehrer, ein dummheit!

3) Comment by Chucky - 30/08/2011

Wow DMJ sounds like you can not wait for the demise of the White race. The TEA party is made up from all demographics and from all areas of America, city and country . The TEA party has already done their job you and others have heard them and the message now you take sides.

4) Comment by julwood - 29/08/2011

Our beloved president George W. Bush said it best, "If you are not for us, then you are against us." Tea Party people are patriots and Christians trying to save this country. Therefore, if you are not for what the Tea Party stands for, then you are an enemy of the country and should be treated as such. Unfortunately, maybe only Michelle Bachmann understands this important principle. Barry Goldwater said, "Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice." We should heed our Republican leadership.

5) Comment by julwood - 29/08/2011



6) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2011

a lot of hate today ; if I may I'd like to paraphrase a comment from another piece ; "don't lie dude. You don't have any conservative friends. If you did, you wouldn't speak of them in the way you do every day. No conservative would hang out with someone who has nothing but contempt towards them" ...

7) Comment by DMJ - 29/08/2011

The GOP is singing its swan song....much like the hippy movement of the late 60s and early 70s. Sure, the hippies made a lot of noise and even got some things done, but in the end, they lost. (Dick Nixon got elected twice, after all, with the Reagan revolution soon to follow). The Tea Party is the same. Sure, they're making waves right now, but the factors they can't change - demographics and time - are not on their side. The country is getting less white, more secular, more urban, more international and more socially liberal. Republicans will have to face these realities and adapt (change) or perish. Once the baby boomers start to die off, we'll (hopefully) have less culture war and we can go back to arguing about economics. At least then, we don't have to hate eachother :)

8) Comment by twinkie1cat - 29/08/2011

They are not supporting the DNC because we have a black president. I know some white people who are borderline, moderates who could go either way because of certain issues, especially gay rights, which they support, and they voted against Obama because he is black. They admit it. They are totally freaked out by it. They are also freaked out by universal health care because they are afraid that a Mexican might get medical care on their dime. There are a great many white Americans who have not gotten over the fact that they lost on the civil rights movement. Today they are called the Teaparties. I think some people would meet in the middle but there are a lot of haters and they are keeping that from happening. Look at how they held America hostage on the deficit. If that was not racist I don't know what is. Their prime objective is getting our black president out of office. I don't think the DNC is radical. It is just that in contrast to the GOP it appears to be. The Dems stand for human rights and being your brother's keeper. The GOP says that after they make sure that baby is born it can go live under the interstate bridge and eat dirt for all they care. White people and conservative blacks don't seem to comprehend or have not considered the Republican agenda. When they are fronted by people like Michelle Bachmann who signed a paper saying that black children were better off under slavery and whose husband tries to cure homosexuality, and they still vote for them, it cannot be anything but racism. When Rand Paul gets elected even though he would rescind the 14th amendment and re-open the door to Jim Crow laws or even slavery, it cannot be anything but racism . When an active Mormon is seriously considered for presidency when his church has been sexist and racist from its origins and only recently started accepting blacks, but he is not thoroughly questioned about his beliefs, that is racist.

9) Comment by NewsReader - 29/08/2011

twinkie, why is it racist for white people not to support the DNC? Using your logic it was racist of minorities not to vote for McCain, right? Maybe some people will finally start to realize it isn't always about race so quit playing that card. Maybe also if people started realizing our best economic times were when we had a DNC president and a GOP house (like now and like during Clinton) then they would realize that indicates the best format for the country is a division that causes compromise. And seeing as it appears the majority of people find both the DNC and the GOP becoming too radical, the time for a compromising middle of the road independent party is long overdue.

10) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2011

twinkie , please re-read ; "Increasing numbers of white voters have left the Democratic Party in the last decade but many have chosen an independent or other party option instead of moving to the GOP, according to state records" ...

11) Comment by twinkie1cat - 29/08/2011

Hopefully many of the Republicans are RINOS and while they may go along with the crowd in public so they won't lose their job or get kicked out of their church, in the privacy of the voting booth they will get rid of the heathen Republicans and we can have a modicum of sanity and Christianity return to this state. God knows I wish Edwin Edwards would challenge Bobby! If he can't he needs to run his wife. This was done in Alabama. When George C. Wallace finished his second term, he put his wife up for governor. She won, of course. After her term he ran again.

12) Comment by twinkie1cat - 29/08/2011

Are the white people in this state so backwards and racist that they don't want to be part of the same party as the black people?? Anyone with good sense knows the Republicans are out to destroy America and yet not only are white characterized as conservative, but they are acting on the stereotype. This racism has got to go. God does not like it. "Hispanic" is not a race. It is an ethnic group and they can be of either African origin, like many Brazilians or of European origin like the Spaniards. Calling them a race is like calling Jews a race. They are not. They are a religion. Here are the races. Caucasoid (white) Mongoloid (Asian) Negroid (African) and Australoid (Australian Aborigines).

13) Comment by twinkie1cat - 29/08/2011

There IS a penalty involved in how you register to vote. Louisiana has closed primaries so the voting is restricted to registered members of that party. A strongly political thinker would go to the opposite party's primary and vote for the candidate least likely to be able to beat the bad guys' candidate if we had open primaries.

14) Comment by KB - 29/08/2011

I personally don't think heritage, nationality, or race should matter...we're all AMERICANS (well, most of us anyway)!

15) Comment by KB - 29/08/2011

Do I dare mention the American Indian???

16) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2011

DMJ ; oxymoron ; it is an interesting thought , just what are the spanish . just as calling someone an "indian" who has never been to India , although I have lived in Indiana , my apologies for the sarcasm ...

17) Comment by DMJ - 29/08/2011

Don't engage Being Stupid. He's baiting you, being stupid on purpose to get a rise, hence the name.

18) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2011

Being_Stupid ; therein lies the rub , european or hispanic ?

19) Comment by Being_Stupid - 29/08/2011

@nimby? How about the spanish? Will the spanish be generalized as "european" too?

20) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2011

Being_Stupid ; another generalization . next step , calling the french , germans , swiss , italians , greek , etc. "europeans"

21) Comment by Being_Stupid - 29/08/2011

The two biggest Spanish States (Texas and Florida) seem to be very Pro-Republican. In fact Florida's Spanish Speaking Cuban Population overwhelmingly voted Republican and caused the narrow Bush Victory over Al Gore in 2000.

22) Comment by Being_Stupid - 29/08/2011

What is a Hispanic? Is this some other made up race invented by the Democrat Party, to further divide up Americans?

23) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2011

I have to agree with DMJ ; the monikers have become more than ridiculous , there 's a lot more than either/or ...

24) Comment by DMJ - 29/08/2011

I really, really hate when someone says something to the effect of..."if you don't like it, then move!" It's juvenile and stupid, to boot. Why is moving to a place where people think just like you better than trying to change your own home for the better? I've never understood the "love it or leave it" argument. As if those are the only 2 options. And another think....just what exactly is an "average voter," agagent? I don't vote Republican....does that mean I'm not "average"? If I'm not, am I above average or below average? See what I mean? "Average voter" is a worthless term, much like "real America." Is there a fake America I'm not aware of? Man, politics is dumb these days...

25) Comment by agagent - 29/08/2011

It is funny that the article mentioned Republican elites, while it has been the Democrats who cannot relate to the average voter because many have had very little real world experiences or successes to draw from.

26) Comment by agagent - 29/08/2011

Both parties have establishment factions, career politicians who are vested in the current political structure and who do not want reform. The tea party is fighting the establishment Republican faction while establishment Democrats have to contend with blue dog Democrats.

27) Comment by agagent - 29/08/2011

The article misses an obvious point. It is not so much about the political party than it is about ideology. The country is increasingly more conservative while the national Democratic Party has turned much more liberal. Conservatives will vote Republican because the Democratic option is usually too liberal. In the past the Democratic Party had moderates and conservatives but not so much anymore.

28) Comment by DaveN - 29/08/2011

Articles in this newspaper are constantly written with an anti- Republican bias, and in this case, misses the mark completely. Specifically, voters are not necessarily endorsing the Republican Party, voters are rejecting the Democratic Party platform. Why is this so hard for the media to print? Voters haven't changed their political view points or their values, the Democratic Party has. Me? I am registered "Independent" and have grown weary of entrenched Washington bureaucrats of both parties.

29) Comment by 8point6 - 29/08/2011

All "white" voters should change their "race" to "other", and change their "R" or "I" to "d". The front page headline in this medium would be: DEMOCRAT PARTY NOW 80 PERCENT "OTHER"! Again nothing said about "Cajun-Americans".......the "journalists" must be racists!

30) Comment by xiangbbu - 29/08/2011

****Comment Removed for Violation of Terms of Use****

31) Comment by dday198 - 29/08/2011

how about bobby jindal he's "other race" . do you like him julwood? im sure that they vote.

32) Comment by dday198 - 29/08/2011

and welcome to the republican party other races

33) Comment by julwood - 29/08/2011

Republicans are doing just fine without "other race" voters. We don't need them, because they just want to support liberal causes. If they don't like the way Republicans run the state, they are welcome to move elsewhere.