‘They’re here because their parents love them’

Advocate staff photo by LIBBY ISENHOWER -- Brittney Byrd, 13, from left, makes pizza rolls with Krista Love, and fellow classmates Ashley Washington, 11, and Teleshia Rushing, Dec. 17 in preparation for their family dinner at THRIVE Academy.  Love attends a book club with members of the school's board, who taught the students at THRIVE Academy how to make pizza rolls before presenting them with Christmas gifts. Show caption
Advocate staff photo by LIBBY ISENHOWER -- Brittney Byrd, 13, from left, makes pizza rolls with Krista Love, and fellow classmates Ashley Washington, 11, and Teleshia Rushing, Dec. 17 in preparation for their family dinner at THRIVE Academy. Love attends a book club with members of the school's board, who taught the students at THRIVE Academy how to make pizza rolls before presenting them with Christmas gifts.

On a recent Monday night, at a time when other children their age were at home, the 17 sixth-graders who attend THRIVE Academy in Baton Rouge were still at school and they had a lot of work ahead of them.

It wasn’t just homework. They had to finish cooking dinner, then clean up the dishes, wash laundry, sweep floors and get ready for the Winter Formal dance the following night.

In a similar vein, this inner-city boarding school limits potential distractions that their peers enjoy, which means no cellphones and a strict, one-hour limit on TV and game-time each night. Family visitations are few, and the children have to do for themselves what their parents and guardians had done for them in the past.

It’s a lot of independence to ask of an 11-year-old, something that is recognized by staff at the charter school, which strives to reach inner-city children at an early age and prepare them for college.

“I would have been scared to be away from my family,” acknowledged Leand Coates, one of three residential advisers at THRIVE.

Teleshia Rushing, 12, said she’s come to enjoy THRIVE, but on occasion misses her family.

“Sometimes, when I get mad, I want to go home and I pack up my stuff,” Rushing said.

Another residential adviser, Maia Young, said it’s good that the students get to go home on weekends and don’t have to stay all week.

“They miss their parents, and their parents miss them,” Young said. “It just would not work. The kids are really close with their families.”

Sarah Broome, THRIVE’s founder and executive director, said the school screened prospective students to find those who could handle being away from home.

Three of the original 20 students who started in August have left, though only one because of homesickness, Broome said. Three new students will take their place when the second semester begins later this month.

The school employs a paycheck-style discipline system where students earn or lose points. The can use the points they earn for a variety of rewards, including to attend the Winter Formal dance; three students fell short and were only going to get to watch the fun.

“It’s much harder to gain the points than to lose them,” Broome said.

“It’s all about balance,” Coates said. “If you give too much slack, they’ll miss the bus, but if I’m too hard, they’ll shut down.”

On this Monday, two days before winter break was set to start on Dec. 19, the adults are about ready to shut down themselves.

“It’s been a really great first semester, but I have a staff that needs a break,” Broome said.

It’s a small staff. The school has just two full-time teachers, Brittany “Bree” Quinn, who teaches math and science, and Katie Andrews, who teaches English and social studies, for the 17 students.

The school also benefits from two Americorps workers assigned to the school who teach art and physical education. In addition, the school also gets visits from several different volunteer groups, including students from Episcopal High School who stop by regularly.

THRIVE occupies two floors of an old dormitory at 1120 Government St. on the edge of downtown Baton Rouge, the longtime home of the Louisiana School for the Visually Impaired, and will occupy more space over time. The school started with students in the sixth grade and plans to expand by a grade level each year.

Broome plans to hire more teachers next year when the school adds a seventh grade. By 2018, the school hopes to have at least 240 students in grades six to 12 and expects to graduate its first senior class the following spring.

Broome, among her other duties, is serving unofficially as the school’s principal for this year only. She’s planning to hire someone to take that job next year.

“One year, I can do it,” she said, with a weary look in her eyes.

Broome, Quinn and Andrews are all middle-school teachers who have taught sixth grade in the past. Broome taught at Prescott Middle and Quinn at Broadmoor Middle, both in Baton Rouge, and Andrews worked in East Feliciana Parish.

For now, THRIVE remains a mystery to many prospective parents and students.

“The challenging thing is that nobody knows who we are,” Broom said.

Broome said she receives lots of inquiries from parents of children with serious behavior problems who assume THRIVE is a strict alternative school.

“We try to tell them, ‘Think more prep school than military school,’ ” she said.

The college prep part is key to THRIVE’s mission.

The school wants every one of its students to go to college, and go on to graduate from college.

College prep has been a calling card of the small number of schools like it, most notably SEED. That public inner-city boarding school started in Washington, D.C., in 1998 and has been the subject of lengthy profiles on “60 Minutes” and the New York Times. Almost all SEED graduates get accepted by four-year colleges and most, so far, are finishing college. The school has a long waiting list.

Broome said she didn’t know about SEED when she was a middle-school teacher at Prescott Middle School and came up with the idea for THRIVE.

The idea arose from a neighborhood street fight involving one of her students in which someone died. Broome said she wanted to create a safe haven for her students so they could pursue their dreams.

“Almost every teacher I’ve ever talked to has said, ‘You know, I’ve always thought we should do that,’ ” Broome said.

Andrews said knowing her students are safe makes her job easier and less stressful.

“You do worry about your child when they go home at night,” Andrews said. “This takes that out of the equation.”

With college years away, THRIVE is for measuring its academic progress through unit tests known as Edusoft, a testing system used by the East Baton Rouge Parish school system, which monitors THRIVE’s charter contract.

As of November, THRIVE students had shown substantial growth in all four core subjects — English, math, science and social studies — and were outpacing other sixth-graders in the school system. Every THRIVE student was proficient in social studies, meaning they are on or above grade level, and almost all were proficient in English and math.

Their weakest subject was science; a little more than half of THRIVE students were on grade level in that subject. That’s more of an achievement than it seems. Last year, when they were still in fifth grade, every student now in the THRIVE program scored at the lowest achievement level, unsatisfactory, in science.

Quinn, the science teacher, was trying hard on a recent Monday day to capture and hold the interest of her students. Using a series of graduated cylinders partially filled with water, she had them plop in hard-to-measure objects and calculate the resulting displacement. The objects were a pen, a dreidel, then a Russian figurine known as a Matroyshka doll.

“If you can spell that right tomorrow, that might be worth a bonus point,” Quinn said, referring to the doll. “That might be worth five points.”

The final items were all Skittles. One at a time, the students plopped them in, eyeing the water line rising and rising. Finally, they were done.

“It took us 147 Skittles to get 100 milliliters,” Quinn pronounced. “How would we figure out how much each Skittle weighs?”

Teaching middle-school children can be a see-saw.

“They can just shift suddenly from being happy to upset, the whole range of emotions in 20 minutes,” Broome said.

She said she tries to remember that on bad days.

“You wish you could just turn that light on, but you have to remember they are middle-schoolers,” Broome said.

Coates said when she talks to people about where she works, people suggest to her that their parents must not care for their children. She said the opposite is true; the decision to let their children leave them all week is a hard one.

“They’re here because their parents love them,” she said.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (11)


1) Comment by petekelly - 04/01/2013

Noel, would it change your thoughts regarding THRIVE knowing the founder and executive director is a TFA "five week wonder" and a product of Advance Innovative Education's alternative principal certification program?

2) Comment by TLS - 02/01/2013

The title of this story has really been bothering me since I first read it. "They're here because their parents love them". Really? Or could it be that their parents don't want to take the time and energy to properly raise their own children. This, in my opinion is the biggest problem that has been evolving for the last few decades.

3) Comment by bourbon-soda - 02/01/2013

@TLS - Agree on all counts.

4) Comment by bourbon-soda - 02/01/2013

I am not sure where the correlation-causation error is, in the "Lake Woebegone Twenty Years Later" article is, but the article is worth reading just for the facts and figures it puts forward. As before, google [west virginia lake woebegone] to find it; the cite in my earlier post does not work.

5) Comment by bourbon-soda - 02/01/2013

Sorry; when you said "So we would totally expect the students in this program to out-pace EBR students without the support structures these students are getting OUTSIDE of the regular school environment" and "it is totally expected that with those experiences outside of traditional schooling (such as cooking meals together, studying, limiting television and cell phones, et cetera) will naturally increase student learning! Now, to scale this is an issue, requiring incredible fiscal and community resources" you might be heading toward government resources. You and I have been through this before. It is logical to point out that in- school reform will likely have little effect, therefore there is no reason to reform. I seldom heard about the mere 17% of differences in achievement attributable to school when the mantra and drumbeat was that more money to the traditional public schools would make a big difference. Both reform and more money down the same rat hole, are snake oil. It's all just competing pigs at the trough, to me. Given the intransigence of NAEP scores over the years, nothing is likely to make much difference.

6) Comment by Noel Hammatt - 02/01/2013

Fraud is nothing new. My comments about present administration point to a lack of the checks and balances that allow for us to check on claims. It is harder to check on this administration's claims than those of almost any other state. And of course I have never called for any government takeover of child rearing. Nothing could be further from my recommendations, which are to recognize and highlight out-of-school factors and their impact on achievement and to have White and reformers quit lying to the public.

7) Comment by bourbon-soda - 02/01/2013

The fraud is national and chronic, and precedes the present administration in Louisiana. Googling [ajc school testing fraud] leads to a number of cites at the Journal-Constitution, including a recent summary, http://www.ajc.com/news/news/cheating-our- children-suspicious-school-test-sco-1/nQSTS/ . There is no reason to trust any measure of academic achievement. Much of the fraud is criminal, involving government money. The present story qualifies as human interest. To run with it to a conclusion that a government takeover of ever more segments of child- rearing, is not tenable. It would be interesting to know whether parents or guardians keep welfare money based on these children as dependents while a government school bears the economic burden of their maintenance. This could probably occur without commission of legally defined fraud.

8) Comment by Noel Hammatt - 02/01/2013

@bourbon-soda: You raise some excellent points about how scores and data can be manipulated. The answer, of course, is to ensure that independent researchers and the general public have access to very detailed data (using common procedures, individual identities are of course, not revealed) which then allows for a variety of evaluations as to the validity of any results. This current administration, under John White, has removed almost ALL such data from the realm of researchers other than those he personally believes will support his position. THIS is the biggest travesty! The article you referenced has some serious methodological deficiencies, In fact, some of his major mistakes include the lack of clarity in distinguishing between cause and effect. As you often point out, correlation is not the same as causation, yet he makes a similar error in his analysis of WHY scores on locally produced tests rise over time. At any rate, John White has carefully crafted the new evaluation of schools to show much more improvement for his takeover schools... after all, taken as a whole, those schools taken over by the state at least three years ago have the lowest scores in the state! Talk about manipulation of data, they suddenly went from using school performance scores as a measure to using the "gains" in score as a measure... much easier to raise a school at an SPS of 30 to 40 than moving a school from 100 to 110. Makes it even easier when you control ALL of the data upon which scores are based. The Recovery School District uses a variety of measures that Cannell would recognize to hide their failures. Only the raw data will expose this... hence the requirement that we all go to court to get real accountability from the state!

9) Comment by bourbon-soda - 01/01/2013

It will be very difficult to evaluate ostensible improvements in academic outcome unless this is a randomly selected group of students and meaningful, preferably parametric, statistics from rigorously nationally normed tests are provided rather than coarsened and arbitrarily defined categories like "grade level," "proficient" and "unsatisfactory." Fraud in academic testing has been extensively investigated and reported by the Atlanta Journal and Constitution, and by at least one diligent individual at http://www.tegr.org/Review/Articles/vol1/Lake_Woebegon__Twe nty_Years_Later_1_.htm or google "west virginia lake woebegone." This s not to demean the humanitarian aspect of getting children out of abusive and chaotic environments. Newt Gingrich was excoriated for suggesting orphanages or the equivalent for neglected (and worse) children. Maybe it wasn't such a bad idea.

10) Comment by Noel Hammatt - 01/01/2013

In the comments below, spell-check changed my "fifth" to "fifty." Schools account for less than a fifth (17%) of student achievement on standardized tests. So we would totally expect the students in this program to out-pace EBR students without the support structures these students are getting OUTSIDE of the regular school environment.

11) Comment by Noel Hammatt - 01/01/2013

When I spoke as a citizen and asked the new School Board in a meeting to vote to support this charter, I talked about how it truly broke with the mold. Unlike most charters, it actually tries something new. Even knowing that this charter is costing the school board money it cannot afford, (as all charters do) I also knew that it would help to prove part of what I have been trying to educate our community about for many, many years. Schools represent a small portion of the time children and young adults are learning. In most cases, schools, including the teachers and all learning experiences in the school, account for about a fifty of all student achievement. In the case of this school, the school is likely more than doubling that, so there it is totally expected that with those experiences outside of traditional schooling (such as cooking meals together, studying, limiting television and cell phones, et cetera) will naturally increase student learning! Now, to scale this is an issue, requiring incredible fiscal and community resources. More importantly, it points out an important message that our State Superintendent and all of the so-called "reformers" need to get, loud and clear. Schools alone CANNOT overcome the impact of ALL the less than educational experiences students experience in far too many homes and communities. Being safe, sharing in activities such as cooking, homework, planning and goal-setting. These things, unfortunately, do NOT exist in far too many families. This is where much of the "reform" movement fails to make a difference. The "reformers" will not, cannot in fact, acknowledge the truth about the impact of all of these "out-of- school" factors, for it will interfere with their efforts to make money for their friends through privatization, something that DOES NOT improve student achievement, but does help to increase profits for a few. (Like the woman who is coming to talk to community members about the profits in digital learning for the Chamber of Commerce this week. Let us, as a community, resolve in 2012 to open our minds to the truth about the reformers, and to force them to open up the data and prove their case before they totally destroy public education. If the truth comes out about the Recovery School District, about the on-line profiteers who benefit from tax money at the expense of our students, and all of the un-qualified and self-seeking "leaders" of the reform movement in this town will slink away. They can only operate in the dark world of lies, for to open up to transparency would spell their doom! Happy New Year to all!