CATS manager says solution in works for GPS tracking glitches

The parish bus system’s chief executive officer said Tuesday that all the kinks in the highly touted GPS bus tracking system should be worked out by the end of September.

Brian Marshall said the Capital Area Transit System has experienced some “glitches” with the system, which was installed in January, related to server issues with the company, Route Match. He described some of the problems as typical re-calibration issues for a new technology system.

His comments followed a Tuesday night CATS board meeting at which one board member chastised the staff for problems plaguing the GPS system.

“Why was money spent on a system that isn’t working like it should?” board member Montrell McCaleb asked. “Why are we having so many issues with this system?”

He complained that the system frequently breaks down and that Route Match takes too long to respond to the problems.

CATS Board Chairman Isaiah Marshall, no relation to Brian Marshall, defended the system and urged patience.

“The things we are experiencing are not uncommon” Isaiah Marshall said. “Anytime you’re dealing with new technology you have to work those things out.”

The GPS system is part of a larger technology overhaul contract with Route Match for $1.4 million. The contract is covered by federal economic stimulus dollars, but CATS incurs about $15,000 a year in operating expenses.

The bus tracking software, along with other service improvements, was promised ahead of the CATS property tax election passed by voters last April.

At the end of January, Brian Marshall and other CATS managers held a news conference to unveil the GPS system for smartphones and computers that would pinpoint the location of a bus within 15 seconds of accuracy.

However, some riders have complained that the GPS phone app, called Route Shout, is difficult to navigate and often inaccurate.

Efforts to reach Route Match for comment Tuesday evening were not successful. Company officials have previously referred questions about complaints concerning the GPS system to CATS managers.

Brian Marshall said some kinks are common to any city installing a new software component, but added that he didn’t expect the service problems to be so visible.

“We knew there would be bugs, but we didn’t know they’d be that visible to the public,” he said. “It’s being a little more visible because we’ve had server issues.”

He said Route Match was selected because it has a strong reputation with transit system technology and because it customizes products to the individual systems.

“The input people give us, we take it back to them and they’re willing to customize the system to our passengers’ needs,” Brian Marshall said.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (8)


1) Comment by phil - 03/20/2013

I seem to have a glitch too. I do not own a smart phone. Will CATS end up having to buy all riders smart phones or computers with broadband connections so riders can track the buses? Since many poor people can qualify for free cell phone service, how about place a cell phone on the bus so people can call and ask "where is the bus now"? Sorry, but I think this is basically a waste of good tax money that could be spent much more wisely on much better things and things that are really needed..

2) Comment by Hello Baton Rouge - 03/20/2013

Im baffled that rather than striving to do everything in your power to make sure the buses are on time, they decide to pay millions for a tracking system. Put a schedule on each bus stop, make sure the drivers ahere to it and there's your reason for not buying a satellite system. How can bus riders, who claim they can't afford anymore for a fare, afford a freaking smart phone to track the bus? This is like buying a $275.00 car because you can't afford better transportation, and putting $10,000.00 wheels on it. Only this time the wheels were bought with taxpayer money. BUT HEY WE GOT A NEW LOGO AT CATS.

3) Comment by rdj! - 03/20/2013

Well lets see... Operators cant log-on to the system, Android phones indicate "no buses in service" EVER, iOS indicates buses BUT about 20-40 minutes off, Map is a cartoon and not interactive, No bus information (bus number, direction, next stop) listed on map... just a goofy bus, no bus stop information - just random numbers, no route information - just a colored line, no points of interest... on map OR on buses, automatic signs make no announcements, poor installation on buses (issues with disconnected wires and such with destination signs). Looks like breach of contract to me. Suggestion: Nextbus, TransLOC or another company.

4) Comment by TLS - 03/20/2013

I saw an interview on the news this morning with Marshall & Marshall. There is suppose to be a big announcement later today. They discussed that they were a $12 million underforming company and are now a $30 million high performing company. Mentioned 7 new buses and smaller vehicles are expected in 3rd quarter. Also have a new logo and are making changes in the bus stop signs. They seemed very proud of the accomplishments.

5) Comment by DMJ - 03/20/2013

Dump RouteShoute. Get Transloc. It's a much better, much more user-friendly system.

6) Comment by foldgers - 03/20/2013

"...should be worked out by the end of September." - - Really? It is not even APRIL!! This isn't a road being built, why on earth is it taking at LEAST until September? (SIX MONTHS!) Who is the Route Match company and how on earth did CATS pick them? The cheapest bidder or something? Did another city recommend them? If so, what city is it and I guarantee you their bus system is no better than ours.

7) Comment by jeninegiommi - 03/20/2013

****Comment Removed for Violation of Terms of Use****

8) Comment by 8point6 - 03/20/2013

"Efforts to reach Route Match for comment Tuesday evening were not successful. Company officials have previously referred questions about complaints concerning the GPS system to CATS managers." We at Route Match got our money, now, leave us alone.

9) Comment by Duckyluve - 03/19/2013

Glad they are fixing this crisis so that the masses that ride everyday can use their $500.00 iPhones so they won't be late for work