Commission to study return for Bayou Corne residents

Advocate staff photo by ARTHUR D. LAUCK -- Crews with Faucheux Drilling drive pipe 40 feet down at one of the 2,200 sites where 2.2 pounds of the explosive pentolite will be placed to conduct a seismic shoot of the failed Texas Brine salt cavern. The workers, from left, are Miguel Garcia, Shane Landry and Derrick Ross. Show caption
Advocate staff photo by ARTHUR D. LAUCK -- Crews with Faucheux Drilling drive pipe 40 feet down at one of the 2,200 sites where 2.2 pounds of the explosive pentolite will be placed to conduct a seismic shoot of the failed Texas Brine salt cavern. The workers, from left, are Miguel Garcia, Shane Landry and Derrick Ross.

Louisiana Department of Natural Resources Secretary Stephen Chustz will appoint the members of a “blue ribbon commission” by the end of this week to determine when Bayou Corne residents can safely return home, an agency spokesman said.

Experts are being sought from federal and state government, academic institutions and consulting firms to fill an estimated 12 to 17 spots, said Patrick Courreges, DNR spokesman.

“The commission will make recommendations on what the safety benchmarks should be and on when they have been sufficiently met,” Courreges said in an email.

The appointments will cap a busy week of meetings, buyout talks, a governor’s visit to Bayou Corne and key seismic testing related to the failure of the Texas Brine Co. LLC cavern believed to have caused a 9-acre sinkhole in the area, state, parish and Texas Brine officials said.

  • Following weeks of preparation, a special vibroseis truck began sending vibrations underground in the Bayou Corne area Sunday night to aid in long-awaited 3-D seismic surveying expected to provide a critical look under the sinkhole and around the Napoleonville Dome.
  • A joint hearing of the House and Senate natural resources committees starts at 10 a.m. Monday at the State Capitol, the second on the sinkhole in a month.
  • Texas Brine will begin Monday to contact evacuated residents who do not have legal representation and already have told company officials about their interest in having a property buyout.
  • A community meeting about the sinkhole response is planned for 6 p.m. Tuesday at the Assumption Community Center, 4910 La. 308, Napoleonville.
  • The Office of Conservation is expected to receive on Monday critical new data from the state’s 34 salt dome operators that could show if other caverns in Louisiana are in similar positions inside salt domes as the Texas Brine cavern before it failed.
  • The Governor’s Office has not said when Jindal will tour the sinkhole, though the governor has said it would be this week. John Boudreaux, director of the parish Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness, said Friday the visit would happen Wednesday, but he did not have details.

Scientists think the Texas Brine cavern was mined too closely to the western face of the Napoleonville Dome, sometimes called “the edge of salt,” and had a sidewall failure more than 5,000 feet underground.

This failure of the cavern’s supporting salt structure allowed millions of cubic feet of rock outside the dome to flood into the cavern.

That set in motion the creation of the sinkhole, scientists suspect.

The scrambled subsurface also unleashed oil and gas from natural traps alongside the salt dome to the surface and a shallow aquifer, scientists have said.

Scientists think the 140-foot-deep sinkhole is reaching its final, stable state. Tremors indicating underground fluid and rock movement increased in frequency last week, halting work for a day.

On Sunday morning, another belch of oily hydrocarbons and debris surfaced, parish officials reported in a blog post.

The methane gas is in the aquifer and could leak undetected, raising an explosive risk in enclosed spaces, such as closets, in homes in the Bayou Corne and Grand Bayou communities.

Under Office of Conservation orders, Texas Brine is installing vent wells to burn off the gas and in-home monitors.

Sonny Cranch, Texas Brine spokesman, said the company had 29 vent wells installed and as many as 24 burning off gas by Friday.

He and parish officials said that over the weekend, the wells were expected to have removed a total of 10 million cubic feet since the first well began burning gas in November.

Fifty to 100 million cubic feet of methane is believed underground.

Jindal announced plans for the blue ribbon commission last week after meeting with Assumption Parish leaders and legislators.

Chustz will consult with Louisiana Office of Conservation Commissioner James Welsh, the Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness Director Kevin Davis and others to select the members, Courreges said.

He said the commission will look at three key areas: shallow gas in the aquifer, the current and future stability of the western side of Napoleonville Dome, and management and containment of the sinkhole.

Experts also will weigh the potential for void spaces that could lead to instability under the sinkhole.

Courreges said the commission will have public meetings but have private gatherings to work through data.

As part of a court settlement with Texas Brine in mid-January, the Office of Conservation ordered Texas Brine to conduct the 3-D seismic work now hitting a key phase.

The seismic imaging is expected to allow scientists to see the western face of the Napoleonville Dome, a theorized collapse zone outside that face where underground voids are feared and the source of oil and gas is believed to be escaping from underground formations.

Seismic waves created by the vibroseis truck and, in more remote areas, by buried charges, will help make the underground images.

Boudreaux said heavy operations that could cause vibrations and interfere with the seismic work will be halted through March 25.

Cranch said the vibroseis truck is expected to continue Monday. Underground charges will begin being fired Tuesday.

The Office of Conservation has ordered that Texas Brine turn over the 3-D data by April 21.

Editor’s note: This story was modified on March 18, 2013, to reflect that the deadline to submit data to the state Office of Conservation from the state’s 34 salt dome operators that could show if other caverns in Louisiana are in similar positions inside salt domes as the Texas Brine cavern before it failed was Monday, not this Wednesday. The Advocate regrets the error.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (6)


1) Comment by Thad - 18/03/2013

Until pressure relief wells are drilled and then other wells to squeeze cement into the leaking formations it will not even start to be safe. Flares and vents are just bandaids on cancer. Then there the little problem of the unlocated 3 million cu yd void-- needs to be located and made to collapse inward and the resulting sinkhole made in to a lake

2) Comment by conglo - 18/03/2013

• The Office of Conservation is expected to receive on Wednesday critical new data from the state’s 34 salt dome operators that could show if other caverns in Louisiana are in similar positions inside salt domes as the Texas Brine cavern before it failed. How will this data be obtained? Will there be seismic studies done or Environmental Impact Statements or do the 34 salt dome operators just say their domes are safe? If the commission deems it safe & people can return, than Texas Brine will not buy them out. So in spite of all the problems in the past with the salt dome storage do the people take a chance on their safety? The people at Lake Peigneur can not get AGL Resources to do an Environmental Statement of seismic study in spite of the bubbling in the Lake & the disaster of 1980. These companies do not care about these people. About 85% of the people that live on Lake Peigneur work in the oil & gas industry. They just are concerned with their lives and property.

3) Comment by dday198 - 18/03/2013

why did the government and those tree hugging liberals need to get involved with this this is a classic case of government interference. the.private can police it self and do everything better than government.......RIGHT.

4) Comment by morellok2 - 18/03/2013

So if "the commission" deems it safe to return, does that mean the property values will return to presinkhole level??? This could be an out for Texas Brine not to buyout those who want out but have been deemed safe to return. Even if the commision says it is safe, will anyone want to buy property there? Will Texas Brine have to go ahead with the buyout BEFORE the commission report is finalized-this could drag on for a long time.

5) Comment by Mygulfbleedsforu - 18/03/2013

It's amazing what a little national exposure can do. Before Erin Brockovich and company appeared, we only heard crickets. Now there is a veritable antbed of activity. But how sad that those who got teed off enough to finally go ahead and hire the celebrated law firm -- which seems to be the only reason the State and Texas Brine got off their collective duffs, also seem to be the last who'll get any attention. I'm not sure what the moral of that story is.

6) Comment by lovemykids - 18/03/2013

Will the commission be filled with Jindal lackeys? That way Jindal can get the results that suit him and the people that donate to him.