Jindal, Va. governor  tout education changes

— Gov. Bobby Jindal said Friday that education changes that have produced results in his state can also work in Virginia.

Jindal was in Richmond for U.S. House Majority Leader Eric Cantor’s fundraiser, so Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell took the opportunity to have his fellow Republican talk about grading schools on an A-to-F scale and allowing the state to take over chronically failing schools.

Both have been implemented in Louisiana, and they are key components of McDonnell’s education agenda in the General Assembly. They have cleared both chambers, although it took a tie-breaking vote by Virginia Lt. Gov. Bill Bolling to get the bills through the state Senate.

“The time for tolerance for failing schools is over,” McDonnell said at a news conference. “That’s what’s driven a lot of our reforms this session.”

Louisiana’s statewide Recovery School District served as the model for McDonnell’s proposal to create an Opportunity Education Institution to take over failing schools. The Virginia legislation would establish an 11-member board to try to turn around schools that fail to meet accreditation standards at least two years in a row. McDonnell said six schools currently would be eligible for takeover.

In contrast, Louisiana’s Recovery School District oversees 80 schools — 68 of them in New Orleans, where the state took over most schools after Hurricane Katrina in 2005. Some are directly operated by the recovery district, while others are run as charter schools managed by independent organizations.

Jindal said 77 percent of students in New Orleans were attending failing schools before Katrina. That’s been reduced to 29 percent, he said.

However, New Orleans schools run by the Recovery School District still have a D grade on average while those outside of New Orleans received an F in the latest round of grades released in October.

“We’re not where we want to be but have made great progress in seven years,” Jindal said.

Jindal is frequently praised for the Recovery School District, but it actually was created by former Gov. Kathleen Blanco, a Democrat. Jindal has pushed for an expanded role for the district and charter schools, and he is responsible for implementation of the A-to-F grading scale in Louisiana.

“We used to have a star system that was very confusing,” Jindal said.

That’s the same criticism McDonnell has for Virginia’s system of rating schools as accredited, accredited with warning or not accredited. He claims a grading scale that parents already understand because of the report cards will encourage them to become more involved in the schools. Jindal agrees.

“This is all about empowering parents,” he said.

A week ago, McDonnell also had former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush join him on a conference call with reporters to talk about that state’s experience with an A-to-F grading scale.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (10)


1) Comment by Warp7 - 09/02/2013

Does Jindal ever work at his job as Governor of Louisiana! Could it be that he is really a myth!

2) Comment by 1ryben - 09/02/2013

C'mon Jeff, you counter Jwarren's claims about RSD with a 2009 study about charter schools? Weak.

3) Comment by jwarren - 09/02/2013

Nice try, jeffsadow, but the reports by researchonreforms.org, for example the the Jan. 11, 2013, report on skewed RSD figures, at http://www.researchonreforms.org/html/documents/RSDSkewsResults.pdf trump the stanford report from 2...0...0...9.

4) Comment by jeffsadow - 09/02/2013

Nice try @jwarren, but the CREDO studies, among others, pretty much invalidate your claim; see http://credo.stanford.edu/reports/LA_CHARTER%20SCHOOL%20REPORT_CREDO_2009.pdf.

5) Comment by jwarren - 09/02/2013

Jindal's narrative on the RSD is somewhere between a myth and a lie. The truth is out there, even if most people in our state, including our legislators and BESE members, choose to believe the myth and the lie. http://www.researchonreforms.org/html/documentreposit.html

6) Comment by Bouncer - 09/02/2013

Virginians have the common sense not to replicate ANYTHING that is done in this third-world excuse for a state.

7) Comment by morellok2 - 09/02/2013

No data yet to base these claims upon, and with the newly redesigned LDoE website we may never see the real data once it comes in. All of the reports coming from White and Jindal have been so manipulated to "prove" what they want us to believe. This makes those reports useless for anyone truly concerned about the quality of education in our state. By the time they leave for greener pastures, Jindal and White will have accomplished their goal of destroying public education in Louisiana.

8) Comment by Crafty1 - 09/02/2013

"Jindal said 77 percent of students in New Orleans were attending failing schools before Katrina. That’s been reduced to 29 percent, he said." So, that reduction had nothing to do with the fact that most of the low performing kids ended up in other states or scattered throughout La? Funny how they fail to mention that when they TRY to tout the success of RSD. If there were any improvement in RSD the credit should go to Paul V. White and his TFA friends didn't improve RSD and have no real experience so why were they allowed to take over the entire state? I still don't get it.

9) Comment by IMVOR - 09/02/2013

". . . education changes that have produced results in his state can also work in Virginia." What results? Jindal has gotten praise for policies, but student achievement hasn't even been measured. One would assume that better student achievement and retention would be the measure of "results produced." In terms of college preparation or job readiness, basing "results" on standardized testing is questionable even. Jindal and his Higher Education Commissioner have both already said their objective is vocational level training. So, when it comes to education in Louisiana, "results" are relative.

10) Comment by Mygulfbleedsforu - 09/02/2013

Save yourseeeeeelves...!!