Letter urges participation

Jindal says Medicaid expansion to cost La. $1 billion

A varied group of organizations and individuals on Tuesday urged Gov. Bobby Jindal to agree to the Medicaid expansion included in the federal health care overhaul.

“Medicaid expansion could provide health coverage to 400,000 Louisianians, most of whom are currently uninsured, and bring in billions of new federal dollars. It will benefit Louisiana’s families, businesses, health care providers and the economy — all at little cost to the state budget,” the open letter to Jindal said.

Jindal — like other Republican governors — has consistently declined to embrace the key part of the Affordable Care Act, referred to as Obamacare. He claims it would be too costly for the state in the long run and there is not enough flexibility to design a program that meets state needs.

But Republican governors of Ohio, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico and North Dakota have altered their positions in recent days and announced their states would expand the Medicaid program to cover more working poor people.

When he made the announcement, Ohio Gov. John Kasich said: “Ohio taxpayers dollars are coming back to Ohio to support a significant need we have.”

Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer, who has clashed publicly with the Obama administration, also cited loss of federal funds and health care jobs if the state did not participate.

Jindal did not agree to be interviewed Tuesday, but his press office released a statement saying his position has not changed.

“Medicaid relies on an outdated model that costs taxpayers billions of dollars and produces poor outcomes,” Jindal said in the prepared statement. He said the expansion could cost Louisiana more than $1 billion in 10 years.

State Department of Health and Hospitals Secretary Bruce Greenstein said the state wants to see “some significant flexibility, the ability for Medicaid to be in a reform situation.” He wants federal officials to negotiate “in a meaningful way” waivers that would allow states to implement different ideas, he said.

The open letter to Jindal had among its signees the AARP, the Advocacy Center, the Greater New Orleans American Association of University Women, Louisiana AIDS Advocacy Network, the Louisiana Budget Project, the American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network (Mid South Division), and the National Association of Social Workers, Louisiana Chapter.

The groups were among 44 organizations on the letter, which also include about the same number of people signing as individuals.

The letter cites the success of another Medicaid expansion the state participated in that expanded care for children so that only 5 percent of Louisiana’s children are uninsured today — down from 20 percent.

“Medicaid expansion offers a chance to replicate this policy success and makes a significant investment in Louisiana’s people and workforce,” the letter continued.

The health care revamp expands Medicaid eligibility to anyone earning up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level — $15,282 for a single person this year. The program starts in 2014.

Nearly 20 percent of Louisiana’s workforce lack health insurance — one in four adults. Medicaid expansion would cut that number in half, according to proponents.

The expansion would also bring an estimated $15.7 billion into the Louisiana economy over the next decade “that will spur job creation, support local businesses and provide a more stable source of revenue for doctors, hospitals and other health care providers,” the letter said.

The Medicaid expansion would come at a modest cost to the state with the federal government initially paying 100 percent for the first three years and then a small portion after that — never more than 10 percent, proponents wrote.

They also said with the full implementation of the Affordable Care Act current federal funding for uninsured care on which the state relies will start to diminish with no replacement dollars in sight absent Medicaid expansion.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (13)


1) Comment by agagent - 06/02/2013

Where has the money gone? If you wonder why higher education funding has been cut and why the state is handing out pink slips and closing medical facilities, the easy answer is Medicaid. These Medicaid deficits have been or will be filled by cutting other items in the state budget, starting with FY 2014: $355 million, $859 million, $127 million, $50 million, $308 million . . . .

2) Comment by AdvocacyCenter - 06/02/2013

If you are interested in joining the 57 Organizations and 185 individuals asking the Governor to support Medicaid Expansion, sign on at http://lamedicaidexpansion.org/.

3) Comment by Ivy - 06/02/2013

@tradewinns, you got to be joking, right? it used to be if you were "poor" you could still eke out a basic living, and so what if you died from a preventable disease or two, it was the cost of being "poor". the rise of those "dang organizations" came about because what happens to the poor also happens to the rich and I'll bet at least HALF of those organizations came about because someone "rich" had it (preventable disease) happen to one of their loved one and they saw how few resources were available to aid their loved one, regardless of how much money they threw at it. Hence the rise of an organization to help others suffering from the same....

4) Comment by SuzanneMS - 06/02/2013

To say nothing of AARP, American Association of University Women, National Association of Social Workers, and the Louisiana Budget project. agagent, please. You know as well as we do that the reason that health care and education are cut every year to plug the budget holes caused by Jindal's reductions of taxes on the wealthy and corporations is that those are the ONLY items that can be cut. The citizens of Louisiana, in their infinite wisdom, have protected everything else with constitutional amendments. What this state cannot afford are Jindal's tax cuts, exemptions, deductions and rebates to his special few. It might be interesting, too, to start using legislation rather than constitutional amendments, to govern, but that would require the legislators to actually govern.

5) Comment by swinham - 06/02/2013

tradewinns: So in your world the American Cancer Society only benefits poor people?

6) Comment by crazycajun - 06/02/2013

Most of those repub governors are now starting to change their minds now that the election is over. This boy, L'il booby, will ride this dead horse to get attention for as long as he can. When ur right and everybody else is wrong you. would think booby would give pause and rethink the situation. Not this genius. He lives in a parallel universe called "Booby World". This boy really believes the hype motorcycle foster laid on him way back when. But then again foster thought the drive through at McDonald's was a miracle. LOL

7) Comment by tradewinns - 06/02/2013

i dont know the answers to our problems, but to have 44 organizations request help for the "poor" shows WE HAVE TOO MANY DANG ORGANIZATIONS FOR THE POOR. the "poor" of this nation are killing us. they currently have too much, want even more, no demand even more, and do not want to work for any of it. we need to reduce all welfare programs by 10% a year till it's gone.

8) Comment by Holinyx - 06/02/2013

agagent, you got a link that proves those numbers?

9) Comment by agagent - 06/02/2013

Obamacare will cause 7 million to lose their employee-provided health care. Obama planned to force states to expand their Medicaid programs but the Supreme Court ruled that unconstitutional. That would shift many from private health insurance to Medicaid. All the mandated coverage in Obamacare could increase the cost of current policies by 190%, and IRS reports the cheapest Obamacare annual premium will be $20,000 for family coverage. Obamacare incentives and taxes are designed to shrink private insurance and drive people into government-provided insurance.

10) Comment by agagent - 06/02/2013

Louisiana cannot afford its current Medicaid program much less a more expensive program. Almost each year higher education and health and hospitals are cut mid year to fill the Medicaid deficit. Louisiana will need to shift $355 million from other parts of the budget to fill its FY 2014 Medicaid deficit. It is madness to even consider increasing Medicaid expansion, a program which already pays for 75% of all births in the state, according to the Advocate. Reform Medicaid, not expand it.

11) Comment by swinham - 06/02/2013

I guess Jindal/ALEC can dismiss these 44 organizations as communist fronts representing people incapable of competing in the brave new world of every (business)man for himself.

12) Comment by dday198 - 06/02/2013

“If Arizona does not expand, for poor Arizonans below (the federal poverty line), only legal immigrants, but not citizens, would be eligible for subsidies,” budget documents turned up by the AP note. Here’s how that would work: Under the Affordable Care Act, the only American citizens eligible for government subsidies to purchase private coverage are those who live above the poverty line (earning more than $11,170). For legal immigrants, however, things work differently. Medicaid has, for decades, now imposed a five-year waiting period before they can gain coverage. The Affordable Care Act, however, created a new option: Any legal immigrant, no matter how long they had been a resident of a given state, could purchase health coverage on the new exchanges and qualify for the subsidies.

13) Comment by dday198 - 06/02/2013

(Haraz N. Ghanbari — Associated Press) New budget memos from the state provide some insight: Opting out of the Medicaid expansion had the potential to give immigrants better access to health care than American citizens. This small quirk in the Affordable Care Act that Arizona stumbled on could significantly reshape the politics for governors weighing whether to sign up for the health law’s Medicaid expansion. The dilemma raised by Brewer’s budget advisers is this: Turning down the Medicaid expansion would mean giving low income, legal immigrants access to private insurance subsidies unavailable to American citizens.