Teachers facing fines in failed recall efforts

The teachers who led unsuccessful recall efforts against Gov. Bobby Jindal and House Speaker Chuck Kleckley face fines for failure to file timely campaign finance reports.

Calcasieu Parish public school teachers Angie Bonvillian and Brenda Romero are each subject to $1,000 fines for missing a deadline for a report required 45 days after the recall drives began.

Bonvillian and Romero are asking the Louisiana Board of Ethics to waive — or in the alternative reduce — the penalties.

Both said they were not aware of the reporting requirement.

“Angie Bonvillian states that the group of four teachers that started the recall effort did not know what they were getting into,” according to Ethics Board documents.

“Brenda Romero states that she misunderstood the filing requirements. ... She further states that filing the recall petition was her first venture into anything related to politics,” according to Ethics Board documents in her case.

The Ethics Board is scheduled to take the issue up on Friday.

Neither Bonvillian nor Romero responded to email requests seeking comment.

Louisiana Republican Party executive director Jason Doré said he had filed a complaint against the recall organizers when they did not submit the documents on time.

Bonvillian and Romero launched the campaigns aimed at ousting Jindal and Kleckley, R-Lake Charles, because of their role in passing private school voucher and revised teacher tenure laws.

They claimed the laws undermine public education. Bonvillian chaired the Jindal effort, and Romero chaired the effort against Kleckley.

The campaigns ended without either effort gaining the required number of signatures of voters for a recall election within the six months allowed.

The petitions required signatures from at least one-third of the registered voters in an election district. In the case of Jindal, it would have been about 965,000 signatures statewide. For Kleckley, it was roughly 9,000 signatures.

In each case the required reports were filed 56 days late. When they were filed, the reports reflected little financial activity.

The Jindal recall campaign showed $525 in receipts and no disbursement.

The Kleckley effort showed $1,600 in receipts and no disbursements.

The Republican Party spent over $100,000 combating the Kleckley recall effort in two months time, according to disclosure reports filed by the party.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (12)


1) Comment by Being_Stupid - 14/11/2012

ABOLISH FINANCE REFORM. Finance Reform prevents the little person from participating in politics. The established politicians and political parties can afford to hire a professional lawyer to ensure they abide by all the excessive fiance reform regulation, while regular folks or organizations who accidentally get too involved in politics have no clue how finance reform is supposed to work or that they are even breaking a stupid law created by finance reform. ABOLISH FINANCE REFORM NOW ! IT IS COUNTERPRODUCTIVE. It does the exact opposite of what it was intended to do, keep the small people out and the established politicians in power.

2) Comment by Caddy1 - 14/11/2012

This is typical, I am quite sure that these great teachers will have no problem collecting the fine money from the folks that feel the same way they do. Everyone will be glad to pitch in a pay the fines for them as they did absolutely nothing wrong, except try to express their feeling to Bobby Jindal and they disagreed with his idea and he is now going to try and punish them. Why is Louisiana politics at it's all time worst. No leadership, an absentee Governor and one that does not listen to the very people that elected him to work for them. Jindal has lost his credibility with not only the people of his own state but more important to him, his national credibility. He is now running this state as a "Dictator" would and we don' need that at all. He is taking this state in the wrong direction and it will take years to undo what he and his cronies have done to it.

3) Comment by bourbon-soda - 14/11/2012

Hoist on own petards.

4) Comment by Whatnow - 14/11/2012

A perfect example for rating teachers and getting rid of tenure. You can't make this stuff up! No wonder they need unions!

5) Comment by 8point6 - 14/11/2012

But, ms bonvillian/romero , Ididn't KNOW we were going to have a test today! Pleas waive my "F" or give me a "D"

6) Comment by zombee - 14/11/2012

As an educator I understand their frustration, but as someone with common sense I also understand you cannot leap into something head first that you have no knowledge about. Sorry folks, you made you bed, now lie in the $1,000.00 sheets and enjoy. But hey, we all learn from our mistakes right? I am sure you won't miss another filing deadline. Or better yet, you might think twice before letting anger get the best of you.

7) Comment by JenniferW1126 - 14/11/2012

LA Board of Ethics, if it is in your authority, please DO NOT waive this penalty. People need to learn to take responsibility for their actions! You do not get to just jump into things feet first without educating yourself, especially if you are an EDUCATOR! People jumping in feet first without first educating themselves is one of the reasons this country is in such disarray. Nobody bothers to do anything right, they just dive in, then plead ignorance. Not acceptable.

8) Comment by tradewinns - 14/11/2012

while i would give them a break on the fines, politicians miss filing dates all the time, next time look before you leap. it's called doing your homework!

9) Comment by Mygulfbleedsforu - 14/11/2012

LA Board of Ethics, if it is in your authority, please waive this penalty. It is different when you are dealing with an established political machine or even a candidate for office, from when you are dealing with individuals trying to find a voice amid the din. If you have the authority, I can't imagine any better time to use it. Shame on Dore' and The Party for being the bullies they clearly love to be. I hope this is the last of their smugness as they continue to slide into irrelevance nationally. Go, teachers. Gosh I love America.

10) Comment by BoiledCrabs - 14/11/2012

They "did not know what they were getting into" and they "misunderstood the filing requirements." That's kind of like "my dog ate my homework." I wonder if they are any better qualified to teach students.

11) Comment by Hello Baton Rouge - 14/11/2012

LOL @ the irony of wanting to oust a politician for improper handling of his business (at least your perception of it) but not being able to handle your business.

12) Comment by Bighug - 14/11/2012

Is Louisiana becoming a police state? I half-way expect some retaliation against me for being critical of King Jindal.