Coroner: Man who died after fight with police had enlarged heart

Preliminary autopsy results show complications from an enlarged heart killed a man who died early Friday while fighting with four Baton Rouge police officers.

East Baton Rouge Parish Coroner Dr. Beau Clark said final autopsy results for Derrick Dukes, 43, 1455 Roosevelt St., will depend on the outcome of toxicology tests, which should be ready in four to six weeks.

The results will help Clark determine whether Dukes’ heart complications were natural, induced by drugs or both, the coroner said.

Dukes died just before 1 a.m. Friday at an area hospital, a Baton Rouge police spokesman has said. Dukes was taken to the hospital after he stopped breathing during a fight with three police officers.

The fight began at midnight shortly after police were called to Dukes’ home in reference to a domestic dispute, Cpl. L’Jean McKneely has said.

When the officer arrived, he looked through a window and saw Dukes on top of his wife beating her, McKneely has said. The officer walked inside the unlocked home and confronted Dukes.

Dukes “took an aggressive stance,” prompting the officer to fire his stun gun at him, McKneely has said. Dukes was able to disengage the stun gun probes and lunged toward the officer, according to McKneely.

Dukes and the officer fought until another officer arrived, McKneely said. That officer fired his stun gun at Dukes, but Dukes, again, disengaged it. At that point, all three men began to fight, McKneely has said.

Two officers arrived and joined the struggle, which had landed Dukes on his stomach and on the ground, McKneely has said. While the officers were trying to handcuff Dukes they noticed he was not breathing.

The officers called Emergency Medical Services and began cardiopulmonary resusciation, he has said.

Dukes was taken to an area hospital where he later died.

McKneely said the officers searched Dukes home after the fight and found illegal drugs.

Dukes’ wife was not taken to a hospital, he added.

The officers involved in the fight were on administrative leave until Tuesday, when Chief Dewayne White decided to put them back to work, McKneely said Tuesday. The chief made based his decision on the preliminary autopsy report as well as information gathered during the ongoing internal investigation.

The names of the officers are: Sgt. Charles McDonald, Cpl. Jordan Lear, Cpl. Douglas Chutz, Officer Fred Thornton. All four work at the Police Department’s Second District.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (13)


1) Comment by Hello Baton Rouge - 29/10/2012

For those of you wasting your time arguing with Marchiafava, google his name and read the lawsuit he filed against the sheriff's office for committing him (which was thrown out). He should be a permanent resident of Greenwell Springs Hospital. He literally lives his life to try and sue the police dept. Don't take my word for it. Google and read.

2) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 29/08/2012

"Those who are willing to surrender essential liberty for temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." What part of that escapes your comprehension?

3) Comment by nimby? - 29/08/2012

person is alive , driving down the road , encounters someone driving "unmolested" who had a few drinks , didn't happen to encounter roadblock , crashes into 1st person , killing them .What part of that escapes your comprehension?

4) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 29/08/2012

No one ever suggested the Anointed Ones should check for medical bracelets, what ever gave you that idea? I am merely trying to point out the obvious: person is alive, cops show up and use taser, person is dead. What part of that escapes your comprehension?

5) Comment by Chucky - 29/08/2012

@markedwardmarchiafava – This will be my last response to any markedwardmarchiafava post. At the time of an encounter with a hostile person the police have no opportunity to check for medical bracelets or do a physical on the aggressor, some are not fit for what they are doing and risk death during hard physical activity. This post is really for others who may have questions about this death and not for markedwardmarchiafava who will never change his opinion and if his computer allowed would be written in crayon.

6) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 29/08/2012

It's amazing how many persons have managed to die at the exact same time as being tased by The Anointed Ones. Pre-existing conditions or not, it's obvious to anyone with half a brain there IS a problem with tasers. Despite being sold as a DEFENSIVE tool, tasers are, in reality, being used as COMPLIANCE devices.

7) Comment by Mygulfbleedsforu - 29/08/2012

Far_EAST, et. al., MEM asked a rhetorical question. As everyone knows or should know, a rhetorical question is asked for the purpose of making a point. I'm not sure to what extent I agree or disagree with his point. The police have a very hard time dealing with drug-addled brains and they have a right to keep themselves safe, but on the other hand I am becoming alarmed by the number of deaths from TASER-ing. So I am undecided. But to pretend to not understand MEM's point (which is the epitome of being disingenuous) does not further the conversation one bit. Having been exposed to so much disingenuous social and political conversation the past few years, it now grates like fingernails on a chalkboard. Please. All of you can do better.

8) Comment by jedleland - 28/08/2012

i got baited again by our own phony keyboard warrior ill never learn so i take this opportunity to give up for good keep it up keyboard warrior. Home of the brave? Lol in your dreams

9) Comment by jedleland - 28/08/2012

its possible that mark is still nursing some hard feelings over bein turned down for a police job for being bullied as a child for his failed marriage for his lack of a formal education for being locked up in a mental unit against his will after threatening legislators and in general for a life of epic nothingness when he figured he was headed for greater things. Look forward to this post being removed and mark to figure out the difference between a question and a point

10) Comment by Far_EAST - 28/08/2012

@MEM...he didn't prove your point. He answered your question. A question is a question and a point is a point.....usually a statement, BTW. You didn't make a point....you asked a question. your question was answered. See how that works ??? (that was a QUESTION)

11) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 28/08/2012

Thank you for proving my point.

12) Comment by TigerMD - 28/08/2012

Mark, if you were a doctor you would understand that the chances of him dying as a consequence of his enlarged heart were VERY high during that scuffle. Take your conspiracy theories to another story.

13) Comment by markedwardmarchiafava - 28/08/2012

The man was breathing BEFORE the scuffle and DURING the scuffle. What are the odds of dying at the exact same moment OF the scuffle?