Library pay raise dies

Advocate staff photo by RICHARD ALAN HANNONEast Baton Rouge Parish Metro Councilman Rodney 'Smokie' Bourgeois, right, speaks during a debate over increasing the pay grade for parish library director as his fellow council members look on Wednesday. Show caption
Advocate staff photo by RICHARD ALAN HANNONEast Baton Rouge Parish Metro Councilman Rodney 'Smokie' Bourgeois, right, speaks during a debate over increasing the pay grade for parish library director as his fellow council members look on Wednesday.

Council rejects change in next director’s salary

The East Baton Rouge Metro Council rejected on Wednesday a request to increase the pay range for the incoming parish Library System director, a move library officials said was necessary to attract qualified candidates.

The council also voted to roll forward property tax millages for some city-parish agencies, and approved $380,000 worth of downtown improvements.

The pay grade for the library director is $72,388 to $100,202. Initially the Library Board of Control recommended boosting the range to $115,588 to $160,000 but offered a compromise Wednesday of $104,751 to $145,000.

The council fell one vote short of approving the compromise.

Council members Ronnie Edwards, Donna Collins-Lewis, C. Denise Marcelle, Joel Boé, Tara Wicker and Alison Gary voted in favor of the pay grade increase. Trae Welch, Chandler Loupe, Scott Wilson, Mike Walker and Rodney “Smokie” Bourgeois voted against it. Ulysses “Bones” Addison was absent from the meeting.

Stan Bardwell, a library board member, noted that the library system has a $33.7 million budget, more than 500 employees, 12 current branches, and $100 million worth of ongoing construction projects.

“We cannot expect to attract someone qualified to operate a system of this size and complexity at the current salary,” Bardwell said.

Several Metro Council members took issue with the pay increase because the city-parish already paid a consulting firm $160,000 to evaluate and make recommendations about the pay and benefits of city-parish employees, including the library director position. The study is expected to be complete in December.

Welch asked to defer the item until after the pay study is completed, but the council voted against the deferral.

Bardwell said the board was advised by its search firm that the current pay grade would “be a barrier to recruiting a qualified individual.”

Interim Director Mary Stein said the firm recommended a salary around $115,000, which was based on the competitive salaries the search firm sees for comparable systems.

Bardwell also noted that the incoming director, under the current pay scale, would likely earn less than Stein, an assistant library director, who earns more than $100,000 after working 28 years with the system.

“Our incoming director should at least have a starting salary higher than the highest-paid person on staff,” Boé said.

Annette Bookter, human resources director, said she would ask the consulting firm to expedite the library director’s pay analysis.

But Stein and Bardwell said after the meeting they were doubtful expediting the study would help them.

The application period closes Friday and a new director is expected to be selected by Aug. 18, Bardwell said.

Stein said some applicants were waiting to apply, hoping the council would approve the pay grade increase. She also said she expects some will drop out of the race.

The job was advertised with a starting salary of “more than $100,000.” Stein said they could still do that, but there would be no opportunity for raises.

The Metro Council also approved rolling forward millages for EMS, the Baton Rouge Municipal Fire Salaries and Benefits and four fire protection districts amounting to less than $800,000 in total tax revenue.

Woody Jenkins, chairman of the East Baton Rouge Parish Republican Party, urged the council not to ruin its record of not increasing taxes.

But Curt Monte, Baton Rouge Fire Department spokesman, responded that a more important record was that of the Baton Rouge Fire Department, which is a top-rated department.

“If it doesn’t roll forward, we’re going to be $380,000 short, and next year it’s going to be $600,000,” he said.

Only Walker, Wilson and Gary voted against the roll forward.

The council also approved $380,000 for signage, stage lighting and roadside improvements downtown. The funds come from a dedicated state sales tax rebate.

Bourgeois, Walker and Wilson voted against the downtown spending.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (12)


1) Comment by phil - 27/07/2012

You get what you pay for? What happened to the last director? We got what we paid for?

2) Comment by phil - 27/07/2012

Being-Stupid - I get your point and agree with most of what you say. The problem is too many people just sit around and wait for some group to get involved. Maybe if more people actually joined those groups and really got involved then more would actually happen. Just a thought..

3) Comment by Far_EAST - 26/07/2012

...what would be the worst-case scenario associated with not getting "someone qualified to operate a system of this size and complexity at the current salary" ? Would books begin to fly off of the shelves ? Would we forget the Dewey Decimal System ? I only ask because I want to know....

4) Comment by Terd Handler - 26/07/2012

What in the heck is a roll forward? This article doesn't really say.

5) Comment by gary - 26/07/2012

So, we have a library with a budget of 35 million and 500 employees and half of the council don't want to pay a starting salary of $104,500 ? You get what you pay for. Also, Smokie is better than any standup comic in the U.S. he always leaves them laffing. Oh, and Mike Walker doing a little political grandstanding about all city parish department heads getting $400 a month car allowance. laptop p.c. and a cell phone - he didn't know nothing about that! He has been in the employ of the City Council in some capacity since the Woody Dumas days.

6) Comment by Cousin Dave - 26/07/2012

Mr. T and LawyerDan, you two obviously need Woody Jenkins to educate you about unAmerican aspects of roll forwards.

7) Comment by Being_Stupid - 26/07/2012

We need some new curtains for the Metro Council. Get rid of those maroon curtains and put up all white curtains.

8) Comment by Being_Stupid - 26/07/2012

When will Woody Jenkins, TaxBusters, Tea Party, and Local Republican Party attack these "Crime Prevention" Taxing Districts being imposed throughout middle class neighborhoods by RINO State Legislators like Steve Carter, Dan Claitor, Franklin Foil, and the Federation of Greater Baton Rouge Civic Associations (FGBRCA) and their Associated Neighborhood Property Collectives/Gestapos? I want elected officials by the people overseeing the police department and raising my property taxes to pay for these necessary services, NOT a small group of self appointed nosey neighborhood dictators.

9) Comment by phil - 26/07/2012

By the way, I thought we are in a recession. Seems to me that people are competing for available jobs so how about offer that library position a starting salary of $50,000? Besides when we pay too much, the national average goes up and everyone else in the nation in that position will ask for a raise. This is a never-ending cycle and it causes everything to go up. How many coaches, football players, basketball players, etc etc are really worth the $millions some get per year? This has been going out of control for way too long I think. Thank you metro council for that one good move.

10) Comment by phil - 26/07/2012

This seems like the cart pulling the horse. We have too much money being spent on downtown projects already, and because tax funds are dedicated we are forced to spend it on even more unnecessary things while the rest of the parish needs crime prevention and bridge repairs (needed repairs? - according to the Mayor) etc. It must be grand to work for the DDD. Sounds to me like some laws need to be changed. Also we sit inside our homes for years and watch these property taxes increase pretty much at the whim of a few people until we cannot afford the taxes and have to sell and possibly move to another area. Then when we sell our home we also have to pay capital gains taxes in most cases. Lets face it, property owners are getting the short end of that stick. Who passes these laws anyway?

11) Comment by LawyerDan65 - 26/07/2012

Mr. T - Not only that but it also means you will pay th esame rate that WE THE PEOPLE voted to pay at the ballot box. I, for one, presumed and even hoped that as the years passed my home would increase in value.

12) Comment by Mr. T - 26/07/2012

I thought a roll forward meant that I will pay the exact same tax rate on my home as last year. Silly me.