Panelists question subsidy details

State education officials, who were grilled about last week’s launch of Louisiana’s expanded voucher program, said the schools face additional scrutiny before student assignments are finalized.

The state Department of Education made the announcement just hours after state Superintendent of Education John White was questioned and criticized by a state Senate committee.

White announced last week that 124 private and parochial schools have agreed to accept low- and middle-income students, with financing through state subsidies that backers call scholarships and which opponents call vouchers.

The list includes classroom slots for about 5,100 students statewide, including about 1,100 students in the Baton Rouge area.

Roughly 2,000 students are expected to apply by the June 29 deadline.

Students have to meet income rules, and be attending public schools rated “C,” “D” or “F” by the state to qualify for the vouchers.

The program came under the microscope after a news story said a church-affiliated school in north Louisiana with 122 students was approved to receive 315 voucher students amid questions on whether it has adequate space and teachers.

The focus of concerns, New Living Word School in Ruston, stands to collect nearly $2.7 million in state school dollars if all 315 students are approved for vouchers.

In addition, tuition will total $8,500 per student, which is just under the state’s maximum allowable reimbursement and well over the $6,100 average tuition for participating schools.

The school is in Lincoln Parish, where 57 percent of public school students attend public schools rated “C,” “D” or “F.”

White, who was undergoing a confirmation hearing in the Senate and Governmental Affairs Committee on Wednesday, faced a string of questions from committee members about how much review the state did on the school before it was approved for 315 voucher students.

State Sens. Mike Walsworth, R-West Monroe, and Robert Kostelka, R-Monroe, pressed White for details of the school’s status, exactly how much research state officials did before approving it for students who get the state aid and other issues. News accounts have said that students meet in rooms that serve as the church’s Sunday school classrooms.

The Rev. Jerry Baldwin, the school’s principal and church pastor, was quoted as saying that the school will break ground this summer on a metal building that will house 16 classrooms.

Baldwin said new students can meet in the church gym if the new building is not finished in time.

“How does the department approve giving 315 slots and they don’t have a place for the students to sit?” asked state Sen. Ed Murray, D-New Orleans and member of the committee.

In a prepared statement issued on Wednesday, the state Department of Education said officials interviewed eligible school officials to see if they complied with the scholarship law, which lawmakers approved in April.

The second phase, the agency said, includes “due diligence” talks, public consideration of criteria for participation required by the law and how many families apply for the aid.

State Sen. Rick Gallot, D-Ruston, took the unusual step of defending the school in remarks to the full Senate late Thursday afternoon.

Marsha Shuler of the Capitol news bureau contributed to this report.


Please log in to comment on this story

Comments (5)


1) Comment by Noel Hammatt - 01/06/2012

What a difference the writer makes! In other stories about this episode, including versions that have made their way across the state (and nationally) before this newspaper ever decided to write about it, the important elements are quite different. Not one mention in this article about the fact that there has been NO mention of further due diligence in the acceptance letters sent out to schools that have been "approved" to take vouchers. No mention was made of the fact that reports are that students at the school in question were paying $200 per month, or $1,800 a year prior to the vouchers... now the tuition, which is reported in every other story to be increased on August 1 to $8500 (just below the state maximum). This is one heck of an increase.... yes? Not worth mentioning by Sentell though. Nor is the fact that it was pointed out, quite clearly in the senate hearing, that there was never any mention of any further process of "due diligence" until this story appeared in the newspapers in other parts of the state. This "school" is, in fact, going to be produced by this opportunity for vouchers. What proof could there be that this school will improve student outcomes. Why did the powers that be fight so hard to ensure that none of us will ever know how well this school does compared to public schools. What are they afraid of?

2) Comment by timesright - 01/06/2012

Just give them the ok and then engage in "due diligence" . A little backwards, don't you think? We are certainly getting national attention on this piece of legislation in the printed media and in educational blogs. How ill-conceived this whole ed reform is, but not in the eyes of Mitt Romney and ALEC.

3) Comment by iluvbtr - 01/06/2012

It appears that anyone and everyone that completed the application to offer vouchers was approved without any due diligence. Then a Saturday article in The News Star detailed the New Living Word School's method of teaching using DVD's for instruction, its lack of adequate classroom facilities for the students, and the new tuition increase that would take the school to just below the state's maximum allowable tuition. Now all of a sudden the Mr. White is saying the email sent to the new voucher schools that stated, "Congratulations on being accepted into the Louisiana State Scholarship program", didn't really mean the schools were actually accepted. ??? For more details see the complete reporting done by the journalists at The News Stars website.

4) Comment by lovemykids - 01/06/2012

Why doesn't the state just finance the sale of public schools to churches? That way the state could wash its hands of all the problems.

5) Comment by gtinla - 01/06/2012

Must be one of the churches Jindal visits on Sundays. What a surprise that fly-by-night "schools" are getting voucher money.